Book ver Movie or series - Page 2

hobnail · 08-25-2020, 02:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sirtel

Most Estonians can quote it in their sleep.

Good one; I'll have to remember it.

issybird · 08-25-2020, 03:08 PM

I’ll suggest Deliverance.

Both book and movie are terrific in which case I’d usually go with the book, but the absence of the first-person narrator in the movie made the outcome even more suspenseful.

Gandulf · 08-25-2020, 03:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hobnail

After I rediscovered ebooks and upgraded my ereader I looked at my library's collection and they have a lot. Checked out the first one of LOTR and yup, it's a slog and I didn't finish it. And that would have been the 3rd time I'd have read it. I'm clearly getting fussy in my old age.

As good as or better than the movie is the audio book version done by the BBC where they have actors playing the characters, like the old radio dramas.

Often wondered the age of a person when they review or comment about a book.

It is a bit of a slog, that's probably why I have only read them 3 times

Deskisamess · 08-25-2020, 03:45 PM

The Princess Bride book can be odd, if the reader doesn't realize it's meant to be satire. Check out 1 star reviews and you'll see examples of readers who didn't "get it."

But I do agree the movie was more enjoyable.

I enjoyed Empire Falls mini series more than the book, but the book is good. I've just got a thing for Ed Harris and Paul Newman.

I like The Haunting much more as a movie, the 1963 version. The book was supposed to be scary, but I didn't get it.

Uncle Robin · 08-25-2020, 03:57 PM

Definitely The Princess Bride for me, despite having read the book first. I actually enjoyed the book more on the first read as a teen, a few months before watching the then-newly-released film, than I did decades later on a re-read when Goldman's love of his own cleverness and clumsy autobiographical insertions came across as self-indulgent and tedious. The one thing I wish they had included in the film from the book was the way they all banded together to rescue Wesley from the Pit of Despair

skb · 08-25-2020, 04:18 PM

Even the author of Lost Horizon (1937 James Hilton) said that the movie was better than the book. And it was.

issybird · 08-25-2020, 04:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by skb

Even the author of Lost Horizon (1937 James Hilton) said that the movie was better than the book. And it was.

Agreed.

Also, The Graduate.

ZodWallop · 08-25-2020, 04:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by John F

Soylent Green got me thinking of Charlton Heston, which brings to mind:

The Omega Man

PLEASE don't say that the goofy The Omega Man with its disco zombies is better than Richard Matheson's I Am Legend. Surely you must have recently been struck on the head for your perceptions to be so skewed.

Quote:

The 10 Commandments

No comment there. Anything I say will feel like it belongs in P&R

issybird · 08-25-2020, 05:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Catlady

and The Natural.

I thought the book was better.

ZodWallop · 08-25-2020, 05:21 PM

One instance where the book was definitely better than the movie was Girl On The Train. The better half and I read that one together and both enjoyed it.

But that movie... It was a bad movie not because of changes made to the story. It was just a poor movie, overall.

curtw · 08-25-2020, 05:49 PM

If you're not familiar with the story, you should watch "Predestination" before reading "All You Zombies."

Jaws the movie is much better than the book.

Von Ryan's Express, they're pretty close, but the movie's ending is much more memorable.

A Scanner Darkly, the movie is as close to a literal adaptation as it's possible to get

John F · 08-25-2020, 05:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ZodWallop

PLEASE don't say that the goofy The Omega Man with its disco zombies is better than Richard Matheson's I Am Legend. Surely you must have recently been struck on the head for your perceptions to be so skewed.

...

Yeah, that's the movie. I saw it a lot of times when I was younger, and a couple of times since, but it sticks in my mind. Whereas I read I Am Legend recently, and I've already forgotten a lot of it.

Come to think of it, I probably thought the recent I Am Legend movie was better than the book.

[ducks his head in shame]

barryem · 08-25-2020, 07:20 PM

I read "Dr Zhivago" and then saw the movie and, while I liked the book I think the movie was far superior.

I sure can't agree with "The Maltese Falcon". I loved that book. I might agree that the movie was nearly as good.

I have a hard time comparing movies with books. They rarely have that much in common and when they do that's usually a strong mark against the movie. They're different art forms and different also in that a book is the creation of a single mind and a movie is a collaboration.

Anybody remember Allan Sherman? He had a line in his song "Peter and the Commissar" that covers this situation pretty well:
"There's a saying that is true as well as witty
that a camel is a horse that was designed by a committee"

With that in mind I'm not sure I can agree about "Carrie" either. It was an excellent movie but I think the book was even better.

This is a good idea for a thread. I'm glad it was suggested.

Barry

Paperbackstash · 08-25-2020, 08:13 PM

Yes, many

I think these movies are all superior to the book - some off the top of my head, I'm sure I'm forgetting a few:

Jaws
Dolores Clairborne
Brian Depalma's Carrie (didnt' like the book)
Kubrick's The Shining
Monkey Shines (movie great, book not)
Requiem for a Dream
Horns
Terms of Endearment (really hated the book, loved the movie)
The Man without a Face (Book much better IMO)
Psycho -- I love Robert Bloch but his first book was very basic for him and it seemed half-hearted and I doubt he knew what a success it would be later

rkomar · 08-26-2020, 01:14 AM

Apart from "Crazy Rich Asians", most of the suggestions are old. Are there no good recent movies based on books, or are they not known here?

I thought Arrival was an excellent movie, but I'm not sure it's better than the short story it is based on.

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Non-series book sorts with series books	Medieval Guy	Library Management	17	11-18-2018 06:21 AM
Book vs Movie thread	John F	Reading Recommendations	32	10-07-2016 06:35 AM
Unutterably Silly Have you ever cried at a book or movie?	seagull	Lounge	47	03-05-2010 12:55 AM
What Movie/TV Series/Anime Would You Like To See Redone As A Novel	Solitaire1	Reading Recommendations	7	11-20-2009 12:46 AM

08-25-2020, 03:08 PM	#17
issybird o saeclum infacetum Posts: 21,514 Karma: 236076651 Join Date: Oct 2010 Location: New England Device: Mini, H2O, Glo HD, Aura One, PW4, PW5	I’ll suggest *Deliverance*. Both book and movie are terrific in which case I’d usually go with the book, but the absence of the first-person narrator in the movie made the outcome even more suspenseful.

08-25-2020, 03:45 PM	#19
Deskisamess Wizard Posts: 2,775 Karma: 45827761 Join Date: Sep 2012 Location: Ohio Device: iPhone 13 Pro, iPad mini, iPad Pro 12.9",Paperwhite 6.8", Scribe 2022	The Princess Bride book can be odd, if the reader doesn't realize it's meant to be satire. Check out 1 star reviews and you'll see examples of readers who didn't "get it." But I do agree the movie was more enjoyable. I enjoyed Empire Falls mini series more than the book, but the book is good. I've just got a thing for Ed Harris and Paul Newman. I like The Haunting much more as a movie, the 1963 version. The book was supposed to be scary, but I didn't get it.

08-25-2020, 03:57 PM	#20
Uncle Robin Diligent dilettante Posts: 3,662 Karma: 52758936 Join Date: Sep 2019 Location: in my mind Device: Kobo Sage; Kobo Libra Colour	Definitely The Princess Bride for me, despite having read the book first. I actually enjoyed the book more on the first read as a teen, a few months before watching the then-newly-released film, than I did decades later on a re-read when Goldman's love of his own cleverness and clumsy autobiographical insertions came across as self-indulgent and tedious. The one thing I wish they had included in the film from the book was the way they all banded together to rescue Wesley from the Pit of Despair

08-25-2020, 04:18 PM	#21
skb Evangelist Posts: 401 Karma: 1597305 Join Date: Mar 2010 Device: Ipod G4, MacOS 10.12, Calibre, Pocketbook Touch HD 3	Even the author of Lost Horizon (1937 James Hilton) said that the movie was better than the book. And it was.

08-25-2020, 05:21 PM	#25
ZodWallop Gentleman and scholar Posts: 11,499 Karma: 111164374 Join Date: Jun 2015 Location: Space City, Texas Device: Clara BW; Nook ST w/Glowlight, Paperwhite 3	One instance where the book was definitely better than the movie was Girl On The Train. The better half and I read that one together and both enjoyed it. But that movie... It was a bad movie not because of changes made to the story. It was just a poor movie, overall.

08-25-2020, 05:49 PM	#26
curtw Outside of a dog Posts: 877 Karma: 4457646 Join Date: Dec 2007 Location: Houston, TX Device: Kindle Voyage	If you're not familiar with the story, you should watch "Predestination" before reading "All You Zombies." Jaws the movie is much better than the book. Von Ryan's Express, they're pretty close, but the movie's ending is much more memorable. A Scanner Darkly, the movie is as close to a literal adaptation as it's possible to get

08-25-2020, 07:20 PM	#28
barryem Wizard Posts: 2,459 Karma: 68781975 Join Date: Oct 2012 Location: Arkansas Device: Paperwhite 4	I read "Dr Zhivago" and then saw the movie and, while I liked the book I think the movie was far superior. I sure can't agree with "The Maltese Falcon". I loved that book. I might agree that the movie was nearly as good. I have a hard time comparing movies with books. They rarely have that much in common and when they do that's usually a strong mark against the movie. They're different art forms and different also in that a book is the creation of a single mind and a movie is a collaboration. Anybody remember Allan Sherman? He had a line in his song "Peter and the Commissar" that covers this situation pretty well: "There's a saying that is true as well as witty that a camel is a horse that was designed by a committee" With that in mind I'm not sure I can agree about "Carrie" either. It was an excellent movie but I think the book was even better. This is a good idea for a thread. I'm glad it was suggested. Barry

08-25-2020, 08:13 PM	#29
Paperbackstash Wizard Posts: 1,666 Karma: 20102554 Join Date: Aug 2018 Location: Central Florida Device: Oasis 3, PW 3 & 5, Fire HD 8 & 10	Yes, many I think these movies are all superior to the book - some off the top of my head, I'm sure I'm forgetting a few: Jaws Dolores Clairborne Brian Depalma's Carrie (didnt' like the book) Kubrick's The Shining Monkey Shines (movie great, book not) Requiem for a Dream Horns Terms of Endearment (really hated the book, loved the movie) The Man without a Face (Book much better IMO) Psycho -- I love Robert Bloch but his first book was very basic for him and it seemed half-hearted and I doubt he knew what a success it would be later

08-26-2020, 01:14 AM	#30
rkomar Wizard Posts: 3,067 Karma: 18821071 Join Date: Oct 2010 Location: Sudbury, ON, Canada Device: PRS-505, PB 902, PRS-T1, PB 623, PB 840, PB 633	Apart from "Crazy Rich Asians", most of the suggestions are old. Are there no good recent movies based on books, or are they not known here? I thought Arrival was an excellent movie, but I'm not sure it's better than the short story it is based on.

Advert

Advert