2025 Scribe features not coming to older models?

[jake01756]

https://blog.the-ebook-reader.com/20...indle-scribes/

I really hope this isn’t true. I would understand the AI features not being available on the older models, but the new homescreen layout or cloud integration? That’s just insane. The homescreen on the kindles is literally some JavaScript and HTML.

Now obviously we don’t need the new system wide dark mode as the older scribes already have that basic feature.

It does link to an Amazon help page so I’m hoping the language in the help page means “it’s only on these models for now because we haven’t backported the software yet” instead of “it’s not coming at all”. The 2022 and 2024 scribes are not that old in terms of kindles AND they are still in their software support window as well. Those devices were also crazy expensive at launch as well.

[jackm8]

Originally Posted by blog.the-ebook-reader.com

This is why everyone hates Amazon.

Ouch.

Seriously, both old scribes are still lacking in notetaking features, and in UI as well, so it would really be a bad move from them to just abandon them.

[rantanplan]

Originally Posted by jackm8

Ouch.

Seriously, both old scribes are still lacking in notetaking features, and in UI as well, so it would really be a bad move from them to just abandon them.

I was holding on to my original Scribe because I was expecting them to backport the new features. If this turns out true, I’ll sell the device too. The only remaining device will be my Kindle Touch - for reasons.

[jackm8]

Google drive and Microsoft OneNote are proprietary tech, so it could be something with contracts.

[Sirtel]

Originally Posted by jackm8

Google drive and Microsoft OneNote are proprietary tech, so it could be something with contracts.

Google Drive is accessible on some Kobo models. If Kobo can have it, so could Amazon.

[tomsem]

Originally Posted by jake01756

https://blog.the-ebook-reader.com/20...indle-scribes/

I really hope this isn’t true. I would understand the AI features not being available on the older models, but the new homescreen layout or cloud integration? That’s just insane. The homescreen on the kindles is literally some JavaScript and HTML.

Now obviously we don’t need the new system wide dark mode as the older scribes already have that basic feature.

It does link to an Amazon help page so I’m hoping the language in the help page means “it’s only on these models for now because we haven’t backported the software yet” instead of “it’s not coming at all”. The 2022 and 2024 scribes are not that old in terms of kindles AND they are still in their software support window as well. Those devices were also crazy expensive at launch as well.

I don't put any credence in 'evidence' from the Help pages. But neither do I assume the older Scribes will get ALL of the new features of the new ones, which 'bad ereader' claims his Amazon contacts assure him is the case.

There will be some features coming (Amazon announced 'book so far' and 'recap' would be to all newer Kindles), that is all I'm assuming at this point.

I believe it is closer to 'all features' than to 'no features' however, largely because Amazon has done that in the past.

[jake01756]

Originally Posted by jackm8

Google drive and Microsoft OneNote are proprietary tech, so it could be something with contracts.

No I don’t think so. Anyone can build an app that connects to the Google Drive API or OneDrive API. It’s in their best interest to allow it because then users will upload more files and eventually exceed their storage limit.

[Dr. Drib]

"...[E]everyone hates Amazon."

Looks like Nate is promenading his tail feathers for all to see.

[Ebookus]

Originally Posted by jake01756

It’s in their best interest to allow it because then users will upload more files and eventually exceed their storage limit.

I am not to sure about this, storage is a loss leader for Microsoft and Google, getting some people to pay $1-2 for some extra storage is not the goal, getting them to use their other cloud services is.

[rantanplan]

Storage at Google Drive with a "free" (as in "you pay with your soul") account gives you 15 GB. For documents, that should be more than enough.

[Frogm4n]

Originally Posted by jake01756

It does link to an Amazon help page so I’m hoping the language in the help page means “it’s only on these models for now because we haven’t backported the software yet” instead of “it’s not coming at all”. The 2022 and 2024 scribes are not that old in terms of kindles AND they are still in their software support window as well. Those devices were also crazy expensive at launch as well.

Of course the Help pages aren't going to provide directions on using features for models that aren't even running the firmware that has them. IMO, it's simply wild speculation on his part, and a bit of a lame attempt at clickbait. This is the kind of stuff I expect from Bad Ereader, not from The Ebook Reader.