Excellent modern take on Sherlock Holmes

HarryT · 07-27-2010, 03:55 AM

The BBC have started showing a short series of Sherlock Holmes stories in a modern setting. I was sceptical at the idea when I heard it, but I have to say that, as very much of a Sherlock Holmes fan, I was extremely impressed with the result. The first one, "A Study in Pink" was, of course, a rewrite of the very first Sherlock Holmes story, "A Study in Scarlet", and was pretty faithful to the original, with all sorts of throw-away lines that are a homage to the original story. The stories are told from the viewpoint of Dr. John Watson who, just as in the original, is a British Army doctor wounded in Afghanistan, but a Watson very much in keeping with Conan Doyle's original, not the "bumbling fool" so very often unfortunately portrayed in film adaptations.

The stories are written by Mark Gattis, a name that will be familiar to any "Doctor Who" fan as being the script-writer for many of the very best stories in the revival of Doctor Who.

A pretty long story - 2h 25m (without commercials, of course, being the BBC). Nice to have a decent-length drama to tell a story in detail, rather than trying to cram everything into an hour.

I'm really looking forward to the other two in the series.

Did anyone else see this? Did you love it or hate it?

happy_terd · 07-27-2010, 07:35 AM

Sounds interesting. Is there a trailer or teaser video somewhere to check out?

pdurrant · 07-27-2010, 07:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HarryT

Did anyone else see this? Did you love it or hate it?

Yes, I saw it. An excellent production. I'm very much looking forward to the rest of the series.

It's available for viewing (probably just from UK IP addresses) at the BBC iplayer web site until 10:30 on Sunday 15th. (i.e. one week after broadcast.)

http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode...Study_in_Pink/

It's quite fun seeing how much of an alternative universe it's set in. It's obviously one in which Sir Arthur Conan Doyle never wrote the Sherlock Holmes stories. (And so Neil Gaiman never wrote A Study in Emerald, and the TV series House never got made.)

From the first episode, it also seems likely that in this alternate universe,

Spoiler:

PeteS · 07-27-2010, 07:55 AM

Harry,

Totally agree with your review - it was a refreshingly modern take on the old Sherlock Holmes films. The interpretation of both Sherlock and Dr Watson were much more believable to me than say Basil Rathbone or Peter Cushing. I have never really been that keen on Sherlock Holmes either as books or as portrayed in films. However if this new series maintains the standard of the first tale then perhaps I'll have another try at the original tales.

Cheers,

PeteS

Sweetpea · 07-27-2010, 08:02 AM

I'll progam the next episode. And hope they'll repeat it one day!

Adoby · 07-27-2010, 08:44 AM

I agree. I was pleasantly surprised. I almost didn't bother to look, but I am pleased that I did.

HarryT · 07-27-2010, 09:15 AM

I loved the thing with the nicotine patches

.

Sparrow · 07-27-2010, 09:22 AM

I had low expectations (not being a Dr Who fan) and ended up with mixed feelings.
What I thought good - Dr Watson wasn't a bumbling character, the incidental music was good, some imaginative touches (e.g. how texts were used and displayed).
Not so good - Cumberbatch didn't do it for me as Sherlock; the plot wasn't up to much; the villain was disappointing; as was the acting of Mark Gatiss in a role that looks to be an ongoing one (he cannot do sinister; and it's about time someone told him!).

6/10 - I'll be giving the rest a miss

.

Quote:

Originally Posted by HarryT

The stories are written by Mark Gattis, a name that will be familiar to any "Doctor Who" fan as being the script-writer for many of the very best stories in the revival of Doctor Who.

A pretty long story - 2h 25m (without commercials, of course, being the BBC).

P.S. Aren't they written by Steven Moffat rather than Mark Gatiss?

Oh, and it was 1hr 25m.

HarryT · 07-27-2010, 09:57 AM

You are correct - I misread the credits. CREATED BY Steven Moffat and Mark Gatiss, who wrote one episode each. Steven Moffat did indeed write this one; Mark Gatiss wrote the final one.

Sparrow · 07-27-2010, 10:40 AM

What was the significance of 'Rache' being scratched in the floorboards (apart from the connection to 'A Study in Scarlet')?

kindlekitten · 07-27-2010, 11:07 AM

kewlness! I wonder how long it will take to get to the states?

pdurrant · 07-27-2010, 11:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sparrow

What was the significance of 'Rache' being scratched in the floorboards (apart from the connection to 'A Study in Scarlet')?

Spoiler:

Sparrow · 07-27-2010, 11:51 AM

- I missed that connection

.

HarryT · 07-27-2010, 12:50 PM

Sparrow,

Spoiler:

Mike L · 07-27-2010, 01:19 PM

When I first heard that the BBC was doing a Sherlock Holmes for the 21st Century, I was convinced it would be rubbish, but I decided to watch just out of curiosity. I have to admit that it was very cleverly done. Full if nice little echoes of the original (like the "three nicotine patch problem"; and the text message, "Come at once if convenient. If not convenient, come anyway").

Looking forward to the rest of the series.

07-27-2010, 03:55 AM	#1
HarryT eBook Enthusiast Posts: 85,544 Karma: 93383099 Join Date: Nov 2006 Location: UK Device: Kindle Oasis 2, iPad Pro 10.5", iPhone 6	Excellent modern take on Sherlock Holmes The BBC have started showing a short series of Sherlock Holmes stories in a modern setting. I was sceptical at the idea when I heard it, but I have to say that, as very much of a Sherlock Holmes fan, I was extremely impressed with the result. The first one, "A Study in Pink" was, of course, a rewrite of the very first Sherlock Holmes story, "A Study in Scarlet", and was pretty faithful to the original, with all sorts of throw-away lines that are a homage to the original story. The stories are told from the viewpoint of Dr. John Watson who, just as in the original, is a British Army doctor wounded in Afghanistan, but a Watson very much in keeping with Conan Doyle's original, not the "bumbling fool" so very often unfortunately portrayed in film adaptations. The stories are written by Mark Gattis, a name that will be familiar to any "Doctor Who" fan as being the script-writer for many of the very best stories in the revival of Doctor Who. A pretty long story - 2h 25m (without commercials, of course, being the BBC). Nice to have a decent-length drama to tell a story in detail, rather than trying to cram everything into an hour. I'm really looking forward to the other two in the series. Did anyone else see this? Did you love it or hate it?

07-27-2010, 12:50 PM	#14
HarryT eBook Enthusiast Posts: 85,544 Karma: 93383099 Join Date: Nov 2006 Location: UK Device: Kindle Oasis 2, iPad Pro 10.5", iPhone 6	Sparrow, Spoiler: This is one of the many things I was referring to when I said that it paid homage to the original. It's a joke put there for fans of the original story. In the original, Lestrade sees the word "Rache" written on the wall, and thinks that the victim was trying to write "Rachel", and hence goes off looking for a woman of that name, until Holmes points out that "Rache" is the German word for "revenge". Here, Lestrade thinks it means "Revenge", but Holmes realises that she had been trying to write "Rachel".

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Fascinating NYT article on Sherlock Holmes copyright	ekaser	News	18	01-23-2010 12:40 PM
Vook's Sherlock Holmes App (mediabistro)	Nate the great	News	27	01-09-2010 01:49 PM
sherlock holmes question.	oncdoc	Reading Recommendations	9	11-05-2009 03:21 AM
Sherlock Holmes Omnibus	pilotbob	Reading Recommendations	7	12-01-2008 05:42 PM
Sherlock Holmes by Arthur Conan Doyle	yokos	iRex	3	02-23-2007 11:36 AM

07-27-2010, 07:35 AM	#2
happy_terd Banned Posts: 13,045 Karma: 10105011 Join Date: Jan 2010 Location: Finally made it to Walmart. Device: PRS 420	Sounds interesting. Is there a trailer or teaser video somewhere to check out?

07-27-2010, 07:55 AM	#4
PeteS Enthusiast Posts: 31 Karma: 540 Join Date: Dec 2009 Device: PRS-300	Harry, Totally agree with your review - it was a refreshingly modern take on the old Sherlock Holmes films. The interpretation of both Sherlock and Dr Watson were much more believable to me than say Basil Rathbone or Peter Cushing. I have never really been that keen on Sherlock Holmes either as books or as portrayed in films. However if this new series maintains the standard of the first tale then perhaps I'll have another try at the original tales. Cheers, PeteS

07-27-2010, 08:02 AM	#5
Sweetpea Grand Sorcerer Posts: 9,707 Karma: 32763414 Join Date: Dec 2008 Location: Krewerd Device: Pocketbook Inkpad 4 Color; Samsung Galaxy Tab S6	I'll progam the next episode. And hope they'll repeat it one day!

07-27-2010, 08:44 AM	#6
Adoby Handy Elephant Posts: 1,737 Karma: 26785684 Join Date: Dec 2009 Location: Southern Sweden, far out in the quiet woods Device: Samsung Galaxy Tab S8 Ultra	I agree. I was pleasantly surprised. I almost didn't bother to look, but I am pleased that I did.

07-27-2010, 09:15 AM	#7
HarryT eBook Enthusiast Posts: 85,544 Karma: 93383099 Join Date: Nov 2006 Location: UK Device: Kindle Oasis 2, iPad Pro 10.5", iPhone 6	I loved the thing with the nicotine patches .

07-27-2010, 09:57 AM	#9
HarryT eBook Enthusiast Posts: 85,544 Karma: 93383099 Join Date: Nov 2006 Location: UK Device: Kindle Oasis 2, iPad Pro 10.5", iPhone 6	You are correct - I misread the credits. CREATED BY Steven Moffat and Mark Gatiss, who wrote one episode each. Steven Moffat did indeed write this one; Mark Gatiss wrote the final one.

07-27-2010, 10:40 AM	#10
Sparrow Wizard Posts: 4,395 Karma: 1358132 Join Date: Nov 2007 Location: UK Device: Palm TX, CyBook Gen3	What was the significance of 'Rache' being scratched in the floorboards (apart from the connection to 'A Study in Scarlet')?

07-27-2010, 11:07 AM	#11
kindlekitten Professional Adventuress Posts: 13,368 Karma: 50260224 Join Date: Sep 2009 Location: The Olympic Peninsula on the OTHER Washington! (the big green clean one on the west coast!) Device: Kindle, the original! Times Two! and gifting an International Kindle	kewlness! I wonder how long it will take to get to the states?

07-27-2010, 11:51 AM	#13
Sparrow Wizard Posts: 4,395 Karma: 1358132 Join Date: Nov 2007 Location: UK Device: Palm TX, CyBook Gen3	- I missed that connection .

07-27-2010, 01:19 PM	#15
Mike L Wizard Posts: 1,479 Karma: 3846231 Join Date: Apr 2009 Location: Edinburgh, Scotland Device: Kindle 3, Samsung Galaxy	When I first heard that the BBC was doing a Sherlock Holmes for the 21st Century, I was convinced it would be rubbish, but I decided to watch just out of curiosity. I have to admit that it was very cleverly done. Full if nice little echoes of the original (like the "three nicotine patch problem"; and the text message, "Come at once if convenient. If not convenient, come anyway"). Looking forward to the rest of the series.