03-05-2018, 10:25 PM | #31 | |
Grand Sorcerer
Posts: 7,032
Karma: 39379388
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: near Philadelphia USA
Device: Kindle Kids Edition, Fire HD 10 (11th generation)
|
Quote:
-- Colombia is Life + 80 -- Yemen is Life + 30 -- Eritrea is 50 years after publication -- The Marshall Islands doesn't have copyright Smaller countries don't count? In my opinion, that would be unprincipled. Blocking, say, Yemen -- or South Korea -- just because it's a pain to differentiate it from Europe, would be disrespectful to their readers. Also, bigger countries may have more complex laws having exceptions only found in case law. In order to really say that a book is, or is not, in the public domain, in even one foreign country, would take a long legal analysis by someone familiar with how to do legal research in that nation. It might even be that there's no real way to know a nation's policy, on old-book copyright, without a court case. By giving in to the German courts, and blocking their site in Germany, even temporarily, Project Gutenberg is going down an impractical road. |
|
03-06-2018, 12:55 AM | #32 |
Grand Sorcerer
Posts: 11,732
Karma: 128354696
Join Date: May 2009
Location: 26 kly from Sgr A*
Device: T100TA,PW2,PRS-T1,KT,FireHD 8.9,K2, PB360,BeBook One,Axim51v,TC1000
|
I see no reason why Gutenberg needs to go to the trouble and expense of dual sites.
One open site operating by US law has served them fine for decades. Nobody gets excluded unless their government volunteers them to be blocked. They can post an online signup sheet for the governments asking to be blocked. That much they can do at minimal cost. Alternatively, they can block everybody outside the US and its territories. One time move, all conflicts resolved. Anybody wanting access from outside can get their own IP spoofing VPN. Either way works. |
03-06-2018, 01:29 AM | #33 | |
Unicycle Daredevil
Posts: 13,923
Karma: 185041098
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: Planet of the Pudding Brains
Device: Aura HD (R.I.P. After six years the USB socket died.) tolino shine 3
|
Quote:
According to his own diary, Goebbels himself had sold the rights to his diaries to the Nazi party's publishing house in 1936. He received 250,000 Reichsmarks at once and 100,000 yearly - five times his minister's salary. After the end of the Third Reich, the state of Bavaria became the rightful owner of the copyright, just like for Hitler's Mein Kampf, but for some reason they never enforced it. In 1955 some Goebbels relatives sold the rights to Goebbels' works (which they never had for the diaries) to a Swiss banker and Nazi, who successfully claimed copyright from then on. Never underestimate old Nazi allegiances in the German judicial system. Source for my short summary (in German, unfortunately): https://www.welt.de/geschichte/zweit...ebuechern.html EDIT: A footnote. *) Cordula Schacht, daughter of former Nazi Reichsbank president Hjalmar Schacht, who represented the estate of the Swiss Nazi banker who had bought the rights to Goebbels' works in 1955. EDIT: I had originally written that Goebbels had sold the rights to all his works. But he only sold the rights to his diaries. I have corrected that, and added that this fact is according to his own diary entry. The contracts were lost, unfortunately, and that is probably how that horrible Swiss Nazi banker, Francois Genoud, managed to cash in on them for decades. Last edited by doubleshuffle; 03-06-2018 at 07:08 AM. |
|
03-06-2018, 06:42 AM | #34 | |
Wizard
Posts: 4,742
Karma: 246906703
Join Date: Dec 2011
Location: USA
Device: Oasis 3, Oasis 2, PW3, PW1, KT
|
Quote:
Sorry, also in German only: http://www.spiegel.de/kultur/gesells...a-1068642.html |
|
03-06-2018, 06:58 AM | #35 | |
Grand Sorcerer
Posts: 5,582
Karma: 22735033
Join Date: Dec 2010
Device: Kindle PW2
|
Quote:
For more information (in English) see the IFZ website. |
|
03-06-2018, 09:16 AM | #36 |
Fanatic
Posts: 514
Karma: 2954711
Join Date: May 2006
|
In any case, regardless of whether it's for purposes of contract law or copyright, web sites that deal in media restricted by region have shown it's possible to geo-block by region. The geo-blocking isn't completely effective and can be easily circumvented by those who know how--but then, DRM on ebooks, movies, etc. isn't completely effective either and can also be easily circumvented by those who know how, yet the publishers and studios still clamor for it.
In that light, I predict courts are going to be a lot more likely to say, "Well? If you can geo-block, then why aren't you?" |
03-06-2018, 10:39 AM | #37 |
Klak
Posts: 174
Karma: 150374
Join Date: Sep 2011
Location: Belgrade, Serbia
Device: many
|
from my ip provider in serbia only html & Plain Text UTF-8 is available, epub and mobi links are blocked.
-------- March 5 2018: There are some problems with the automated software used to prevent abuse of the Web site (mainly to prevent mass downloads from hurting site performance for everyone else). A set of fixes were applied, and there are still some unintentional blocks. These seem to mainly impact downloads of epub and mobi (Kindle) formatted eBooks. The HTML ("Read this book online") links seem to work better. Apologies for this problem. We will continue to apply fixes and updates. ------ |
03-06-2018, 10:51 AM | #38 |
Guru
Posts: 603
Karma: 12345678
Join Date: Jan 2015
Location: Canada
Device: none
|
I'm now impressed with the lack of action by Harper-Collins in regards to the Canadian public domain sites offering C. S. Lewis titles for download.
And given the number of cheap versions to be found on amazon.ca the copyright holder for the early Wodehouse books seems to have conceded the field. |
03-06-2018, 11:30 AM | #39 | |
Grand Sorcerer
Posts: 11,732
Karma: 128354696
Join Date: May 2009
Location: 26 kly from Sgr A*
Device: T100TA,PW2,PRS-T1,KT,FireHD 8.9,K2, PB360,BeBook One,Axim51v,TC1000
|
Quote:
Does gutenberg advertise in Germany? Do they have local servers or proxy? Is their website in german? What presence do they have in germany? They are not a commercial business. They are actively doing nothing illegal. It is the german citizens who are (maybe) violating copyright. If Holtzbrink has an issue with an American company operating in american territory, sue in the US. They don't because they'd lose. |
|
03-06-2018, 11:57 AM | #40 |
Wizard
Posts: 1,264
Karma: 10203040
Join Date: Dec 2011
Device: a variety (mostly kindles and kobos)
|
According to the court's judgement (which you can read here in English and of course in German) there's no need to prove that the PG site targeted German users, merely that the books were still under copyright in Germany and had been made available there.
They go on however to argue that it was targeting German users because:
(see page 10 of the linked doc) Anyway, those are the court's arguments. I would think that if intent is indeed not a factor, merely availability and protected status, then the big issue becomes jurisdiction. The court seems to think not only can it claim jurisdiction but that it will be able to enforce it. And by geo-blocking the site, even pending appeal, PG would seem to be lending some weight to that. |
03-06-2018, 01:40 PM | #41 |
Wizard
Posts: 2,985
Karma: 18343081
Join Date: Oct 2010
Location: Sudbury, ON, Canada
Device: PRS-505, PB 902, PRS-T1, PB 623, PB 840, PB 633
|
I hope not. As mentioned above, they are just trying to avoid looking like they don't care what the court says, because that can turn the court against them. It is not an admission that they believe that the activity is wrong in the first place.
|
03-06-2018, 02:50 PM | #42 |
Evangelist
Posts: 482
Karma: 2267928
Join Date: Nov 2015
Device: none
|
They have no other choice, as they would be hit by DMCA order if they've failed to comply.
|
03-06-2018, 03:27 PM | #43 |
Fanatic
Posts: 514
Karma: 2954711
Join Date: May 2006
|
There's this tendency people have of treating stuff on the Internet as if it happens in some far-away nebulous Internet-land, above the paltry concerns of real-world law enforcement. But as this decision shows, that's not really the case.
It wasn't necessary for Project Gutenberg to have servers or advertising in Germany. It's making books available in Germany, just as surely as if it sat just outside the German borders and flung paper copies over the wall by catapult. It's nothing new for file downloads to be treated as if they happened locally to where the downloading computer is; that's why Amazon can't sell particular ebooks in Germany unless they have licensed the right to sell those books there, even if they're selling them strictly from servers in the USA (and even if they could sell paper editions of those same books to German customers from warehouses in the USA). Why should the German publisher have to go to the expense of traveling all the way to America to litigate against this? The harm to that publisher's German sales is happening in Germany. It might be different if this were a matter having to do with an American website offering materials that went against a foreign country's religious or moral codes, because America has the freedom of speech that many repressive regimes do not. (And, indeed, most repressive regimes that might be inclined to make that kind of trouble have instead implemented their own national "Great Firewalls," so they don't have to rely on something as potentially chancy as enforcement overseas of a local court opinion.) But this is a matter pertaining to copyright, as codified by international treaties to which both Germany and the USA are signatories. This isn't a freedom-of-speech matter, it's a copyright violation matter. Given that commercial ebook stores had to start minding where they were selling starting in 2009, I'm just surprised it took so long for Project Gutenberg to come to a foreign rights-holder's attention. They had to realize it was going to happen sooner or later. They're going to have to start paying more attention to foreign publishers' requests to block availability of given books in their countries, and perhaps figure out some way of doing that cheaply and easily so such requests won't cost them as much in the future. Because this is surely going to happen more and more often as overseas ebook markets start to catch up with the USA's. |
03-06-2018, 03:28 PM | #44 | |
Wizard
Posts: 3,168
Karma: 37800000
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: Walton-on-Thames, Surrey, England, UK
Device: Kindle Keyboard 3G, Kindle Fire 2, NOOK ST, Kindle HDX, Fire 7"
|
Quote:
If someone runs a US publisher site which allows e-book sales world wide, can the UK publisher of the same book require them to install geographical restrictions on their servers? If so, has this ever happened? |
|
03-06-2018, 04:08 PM | #45 |
Wizard
Posts: 1,738
Karma: 26006874
Join Date: Sep 2017
Device: PW3, Fire HD8 Gen7, Moto G7, Sansa Clip v2, Ruizu X26
|
Seems to me that if Germany wants to block its inhabitants from accessing something that is legal elsewhere, then it is Germany that needs to do the blocking.
It's kind of like China and their copying of US products (they copy other countries as well, I'm just using "US" here for ease of typing). China makes cheap imitations and sells them for less. Often times making their product look so superficially like the real product as to make it hard to tell the difference without close inspection. Do the US producers like that? Certainly not. But US laws against such behavior are not enforceable in China. What if someone like North Korea decided that their people are not allowed to read books (they may have already done this - wouldn't surprise me). Does that mean that US eBook companies would have to block all North Korean IP addresses as a result? (Forget for the moment that very few in North Korea have internet access, and those that do, probably can't get outside of the North Korean infrastructure in the first place.) |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
gutenberg.org blockt deutsche IP-Adressen | doubleshuffle | Deutsches Forum | 14 | 11-05-2021 04:48 AM |
Gutenberg.org : "Read this book online" feature broken? | swamp thing | General Discussions | 9 | 06-05-2014 10:03 PM |
Add german Gutenberg Projekt as dealer? | cremofix | Library Management | 0 | 12-19-2011 04:31 AM |
Kindle v.2 Problems with MOBI TOC from Gutenberg.org | Sonist | Amazon Kindle | 2 | 06-15-2009 04:34 PM |
gutenberg.com is not gutenberg.org | ProDigit | News | 2 | 11-21-2008 12:39 PM |