02-19-2008, 11:26 AM | #16 | |
Grand Sorcerer
Posts: 11,470
Karma: 13095790
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Grass Valley, CA
Device: EB 1150, EZ Reader, Literati, iPad 2 & Air 2, iPhone 7
|
Quote:
https://wiki.mobileread.com/wiki/MobileRead Dale |
|
02-19-2008, 08:19 PM | #17 | ||
Grand Sorcerer
Posts: 7,452
Karma: 7185064
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Linköpng, Sweden
Device: Kindle Voyage, Nexus 5, Kindle PW
|
Quote:
Quote:
And is it the law in Canada you are talking about here? How is the first paragraph compatible with the later observation that the law is different in each country? And the principle used to get to these policies are not visible. |
||
02-19-2008, 08:23 PM | #18 |
Grand Sorcerer
Posts: 7,452
Karma: 7185064
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Linköpng, Sweden
Device: Kindle Voyage, Nexus 5, Kindle PW
|
That is perfectly OK. What I reacted extemely negative to was the position that you withheld information depending on who asked the question. On one level that is assuming that people are stupid and have to be protected from themselves. And it also restricts information to all other people living in other countries reading the thread and having the same question.
|
02-19-2008, 11:22 PM | #19 | |
Grand Sorcerer
Posts: 11,470
Karma: 13095790
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Grass Valley, CA
Device: EB 1150, EZ Reader, Literati, iPad 2 & Air 2, iPhone 7
|
Quote:
The law in different parts of the world has differences but generally these are only in time or details. In general these details may be pointed out if known but breaking DRM of any kind in any part of the world will not be posted here if we are aware of it, even if someone happens to live where it is not illegal to break DRM, since we have no idea who might be reading it and providing these instructions is against our policy. Does that make it clearer? Now for eBooks that are posted on the web site we will obey Canadian law but the user should be aware that they may or may not be breaking the law to download the file we post. Even someone might be breaking the law to post a file depending on where they live. We will not be enforcing those kinds of differences since we cannot in any event and there is no legal obligation for the place you say you live is true so we won't be using that except as guidance to help someone. At least that is what I meant when I wrote it and what I presume Alex and other meant when they approved it. If I have misinterpreted this and other discussions we have had privately among the moderators I am sure someone else will jump in. Dale |
|
02-19-2008, 11:35 PM | #20 | ||
Gizmologist
Posts: 11,615
Karma: 929550
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Republic of Texas Embassy at Jackson, TN
Device: Pocketbook Touch HD3
|
That's a slight mis-quote, the original reads "copyright law or DRM." This means that, to the extent possible, we will not allow posting of infringing material, nor instructions showing someone how to break DRM or other unlawful acts (whatever those may be) or requests for instructions on how do do such things.
Quote:
We do recognize that there some countries don't have restrictions on removal of DRM (or copyright infringement, or any number of other things for that matter), and while we're not going to pretend that it ain't so, we're also not going to host detailed discussions of how to remove it, tools to remove it, or direct links to any of the above (or anything that falls in that general category). We're being a bit over cautious on that particular point because lawyers (and the people who employ them) are particularly nasty and tenacious on the subject. This does not, however, extend to the discussion, in non-specific terms of DRM removal or even copyright infringement, nor to how things are or ought to be. Nor does it preclude discussion of or even instructions for the use of tools in that can be used for activities that aren't illegal. For instance, ConvertLIT was mentioned specifically: it can be used to remove DRM, but that's not it's sole use, so discussion of its use, even specific instructions isn't off limits, so long as the instructions aren't on how to remove DRM. If those instructions happen to provide sufficient information that someone could figure out on their own the specifics of using the tool to break DRM, well that's not something we really can police, nor do we intend to even try. There's enough to worry about that is specifically illegal, or which will get us into trouble to fuss about such indirect things. They're not explicitly spelled out within the policy, no, and perhaps they could be more clearly stated, but they're basically implied in the first paragraph: Quote:
EDIT: Plus what DaleDe said. Last edited by NatCh; 02-19-2008 at 11:37 PM. Reason: . |
||
02-20-2008, 07:55 PM | #21 | |
Grand Sorcerer
Posts: 7,452
Karma: 7185064
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Linköpng, Sweden
Device: Kindle Voyage, Nexus 5, Kindle PW
|
Quote:
I also really do not see the difference with saying "It is possible, ConvertLit, google" and telling how to do it. Have i understood it correctly that the country of the question asker does not matter if the answer I give is just referring to that it is possible to break the DRM and give the unique name that you can google? i do not have to point out that it can be illegal then or? |
|
02-20-2008, 08:03 PM | #22 | |
Grand Sorcerer
Posts: 7,452
Karma: 7185064
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Linköpng, Sweden
Device: Kindle Voyage, Nexus 5, Kindle PW
|
Quote:
|
|
02-20-2008, 08:16 PM | #23 |
Reader
Posts: 11,504
Karma: 8720163
Join Date: May 2007
Location: South Wales, UK
Device: Sony PRS-500, PRS-505, Asus EEEpc 4G
|
The two statements are not inconsistent. It is entirely possible to hold a moral view and simultaneously to have a desire not to be sued were that moral view transgressed.
|
02-20-2008, 11:54 PM | #24 |
Gizmologist
Posts: 11,615
Karma: 929550
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Republic of Texas Embassy at Jackson, TN
Device: Pocketbook Touch HD3
|
Personally, I have strong moral objections to getting sued!
Joking aside, morals and ethics determine how a person responds to legal matters, and laws are fundamentally expressions of the morality of the societies that make them in the first place (witness the fact that murder is pretty universally illegal, but when you get right down to the heart of it, the "wrongness" of murder can only be a moral call). But we have a legion of other threads that discuss the morality vs. legality of this and several other issues. In this case, if we feel some moral pressure to comply with the law, then so what? And if we consider it to be a silly law and go no further than bare compliance, again, so what? In any case, you're certainly entitled to take whatever view of the policy and how it's worded which seems best to you. We've got what we came up with because we feel it best serves and shields the needs of the community as a whole. As it is, it's hardly over restrictive, so hopefully everyone can live with it, even if they don't necessarily care to drink the kool-aid as far as the specific wording or motivating principles go. In answer to your original and direct question: no it is not the policy of MobileRead to try to only give answers that are legal in the country of the asker. Not so far as I've ever understood it, anyway. The answers will, ideally, comply with the various relevant laws in as much as it is possible for them to do so, and very well may carry some sort of disclaimer legalities vary from place to place, but we're not dense enough to think that people in the U.S. (for instance) will only read answers to questions that were asked by other people in the U.S., so that sort of silliness would be a waste of effort. Keep in mind too, that the vast majority of answers around here come from the Community, not the "staff," and we certainly don't try to mind control forum members! We're still working out some of the details on this ourselves, as the move to Canada is pretty recent and we're all still wrapping our brains around the mess that is copyright law. In very simple terms: to the best of our ability we won't allow posting of infringing material (as defined by Canadian Laws), nor direct links to same, nor specific instructions for finding same. Nor do we allow posting of or direct linking to tools that can only be used to break DRM, nor specific instructions for finding or using such tools for breaking DRM -- that bit comes more under the "not getting sued" category than the legality category. If other stuff comes up that needs to be specifically addressed, or if we get a Cease And Desist notice for something new and exciting, then we'll naturally deal as seems best with those eventualities as they arise, including adjusting the policy's language as needed. The language was deliberately kept "not too specific" for the purpose of giving us room to deal with such things without having to change the language every five minutes. If we posted a laundry list of "don'ts" then we'd be open to someone saying "well it's not on the list, so why can't I do it?" Besides, who wants to be that pedantic? I also want to add that, personally, I very much appreciate your concern on this, it's the Community that makes MobileRead what it is, and your interest in this stuff is an excellent example of why that's so. |
02-21-2008, 10:26 AM | #25 |
Grand Sorcerer
Posts: 11,248
Karma: 35000000
Join Date: Jan 2008
Device: Pocketbook
|
I do have one baldly practical question. There are many PD e-book uploads on the site, available for download (all hail to the contributors!), But....under what law is your definition of PD? This is important so that people can compare to their individual countries laws when downloading. RSE
|
02-21-2008, 10:41 AM | #26 |
Gizmologist
Posts: 11,615
Karma: 929550
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Republic of Texas Embassy at Jackson, TN
Device: Pocketbook Touch HD3
|
The books are PD as defined by the laws of Canada, where our server resides, but that only affects which titles can be uploaded.
The point that has to be considered by the person downloading is whether the books are PD where the downloader is. |
02-21-2008, 10:44 AM | #27 | |
New York Editor
Posts: 6,384
Karma: 16540415
Join Date: Aug 2007
Device: PalmTX, Pocket eDGe, Alcatel Fierce 4, RCA Viking Pro 10, Nexus 7
|
Quote:
The site is covered by being hosted in Canada, and making the disclaimer. It can't be held responsible if a user grabs content that is legal for the site to host, but not from them to download. If it's a concern to you, don't download if you aren't sure. Personally, I don't worry about it. If it's hosted on MobileRead, and it's something I want, I download it. The legality only becomes an issue if someone is aware that I've done so and considers it worth the trouble to take action against me. I don't see either of those circumstances occurring in real life. ______ Dennis |
|
02-21-2008, 11:06 AM | #28 | |
New York Editor
Posts: 6,384
Karma: 16540415
Join Date: Aug 2007
Device: PalmTX, Pocket eDGe, Alcatel Fierce 4, RCA Viking Pro 10, Nexus 7
|
Quote:
The one suggestion I would make is a sticky in the forums pointing to the wiki material. I went looking for forum policies regarding this stuff before and didn't find them. It's possible I didn't look hard enough, but it shouldn't require a serious search to determine what those particular policies are. ______ Dennis |
|
02-21-2008, 12:15 PM | #29 |
Grand Sorcerer
Posts: 11,248
Karma: 35000000
Join Date: Jan 2008
Device: Pocketbook
|
Thanks to one and all for the information. Acording to my lookup of Canadian copyright law, it is author's life + 50. (unless there has been a recent change.)
Is there an easy to use coversion program to convert your PD mobipocket editions (or LRF) to HTML? I prefer keeping my PD items in HTML for long-term portability. |
02-21-2008, 12:22 PM | #30 | |
New York Editor
Posts: 6,384
Karma: 16540415
Join Date: Aug 2007
Device: PalmTX, Pocket eDGe, Alcatel Fierce 4, RCA Viking Pro 10, Nexus 7
|
Quote:
Go here: http://www.ida.liu.se/~tompe/mobiperl/ ______ Dennis |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Seriously thoughtful Verso un Forum italiano/Toward an Italian Forum | beppe | Lounge | 262 | 01-19-2022 05:50 AM |
Company policies on e-ink fading in sun when paging | WillAdams | Which one should I buy? | 2 | 05-10-2010 04:17 PM |
Apple Aggregator Policies & Methods | Fabe | General Discussions | 3 | 04-20-2010 01:47 PM |
If Amazon Were Microsoft, Would Kindle 2 Policies Be Tolerated? | estral | News | 29 | 05-19-2009 05:24 PM |
Checked Baggage Policies | Taylor514ce | News | 56 | 06-18-2008 01:05 PM |