10-27-2010, 01:03 AM | #1 |
It's Dr. Penguin now!
Posts: 3,909
Karma: 4705733
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: (USA)
Device: iPad mini, Samsung Note 3, Sony PRS-650 (rarely used now)
|
Sentence Fragments?
This whole book-reviewing thing has been eye-opening for me in many ways. Based on feedback from authors, I sometimes find myself dwelling on some point, and then I post a question on here to get others' advice!
So here is my current "thing": I recently reviewed a suspense/thriller. One thing I commented on in my review was the prevalence of dependent clauses/sentence fragments masquerading as sentences. As is my standard, I put the review on Goodreads and Amazon, and the author commented on both reviews to give a little feedback of his own (which I think is a great way for an author to clarify his or her motivations, etc). Since he did not post his comment on my blog review, I updated my review to add a bit about his feedback and a further comment of my own. Basically, he was indicating that his sentence fragments were purposeful as a technique to add to the plot of a thriller- quick, little jabs. My response? I actually really like quick, little jabs and think they add to a story such as this, but I felt many of his were more like sentences missing a noun. They didn't feel quick or little to me, they felt like unfinished sentences. I did not post that in response to his comments on my other reviews, as I don't think it's necessary or proper, but I did put it on my blog because I wanted to explain my own thoughts on it. So I guess what I'm asking here (FINALLY, she gets to the question! ) is: Do you notice sentence fragments such as these when you read? Do you like them in stories like these, and is there a limit to how frequently you want to see them? Do they have to be short fragments or does length matter? I guess my real question is whether I'm alone in this (or crazy). Where I think it's not great: She was the one that had let them down with her rush to publish. With her overwhelming need for recognition Where I think it's ok: The door flew open and there he stood. Tek. No smile today. All business. Last edited by GraceKrispy; 10-27-2010 at 02:17 AM. |
10-27-2010, 01:10 AM | #2 |
~~~~~
Posts: 761
Karma: 1278391
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: USA
Device: Kindle 3, Sony 350
|
I always notice them. Some, I appreciate. Some are overdone, losing their impact. Others, and the example you gave would be one of them, just sound like bad writing.
|
Advert | |
|
10-27-2010, 01:56 AM | #3 |
It's Dr. Penguin now!
Posts: 3,909
Karma: 4705733
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: (USA)
Device: iPad mini, Samsung Note 3, Sony PRS-650 (rarely used now)
|
huh, I listed four examples, two I thought bad, two I thought "ok" and I only see one! What the heck...?
Ok, added another one. Last edited by GraceKrispy; 10-27-2010 at 02:17 AM. |
10-27-2010, 02:18 AM | #4 |
Snooty Bestselling Author
Posts: 1,485
Karma: 1000000
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Ipswich, QLD, Australia
Device: PRS-650
|
Wellll... based on the one example, which isn't good to go on. I can see the 'stylistic' point, but my personal opinion would be that he's maybe not using them effectively.
I'd write it more like this: "She was the one that had let them down with her rush to publish. Her need for recognition. Her desire for revenge against Daddy. She let them all down and they would all suffer." |
10-27-2010, 02:28 AM | #5 |
Curmudgeon
Posts: 3,085
Karma: 722357
Join Date: Feb 2010
Device: PRS-505
|
Bad writing is like pornography: I can't define it, but I know it when I see it.
It seems fairly obvious where someone is writing for a specific effect and where they just don't know how to use their tools, even if they think they do. You see it with commas, too: they don't know what they're actually supposed to do with them, so they throw them in every time they take a breath when they read the sentence, and figure that'll work (it doesn't). |
Advert | |
|
10-27-2010, 08:08 AM | #6 |
Country Member
Posts: 9,058
Karma: 7676767
Join Date: Feb 2010
Location: Denmark
Device: Liseuse: Irex DR800. PRS 505 in the house, and the missus has an iPad.
|
I would agree with your analysis. The first one is a list of things in virtue of which she has let them down, the second item on that list does not need to be made a separate sentence. The author might have a point though - what effect does the writing have on you, is that effect consistent with what is being portrayed, (for example, a writer might write confusingly, which might evoke in you a sense of confusion, which might be consistent with the confusion experienced by one of the characters being portrayed).
|
10-27-2010, 08:39 AM | #7 | |
eBook Enthusiast
Posts: 85,544
Karma: 93383043
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: UK
Device: Kindle Oasis 2, iPad Pro 10.5", iPhone 6
|
A classic example of a brilliant use of fragments is the opening two paragraphs of Dickens' "Bleak House":
Quote:
|
|
10-27-2010, 08:52 AM | #8 |
Guru
Posts: 624
Karma: 700001
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: New York
Device: kindle
|
I do think (like any tool a writer uses) The sentence fragment has a time and place.
I find fragments to be an exciting way to captivate a reader before or during a scene with a high amount of action. But I also agree that too many sentence fragments will eventually fall under the category of poor writing, no matter how they are used. Sometimes it is even a case of lazy writing. |
10-27-2010, 10:24 AM | #9 |
Feral Underclass
Posts: 3,622
Karma: 26821535
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: Yorkshire, tha noz
Device: 2nd hand paperback
|
I write the other way around. I write long run-on sentences without much punctuation for action scenes and... Short. Often. One. Word. Sentences when I want to simulate something happening in slow motion.
|
10-27-2010, 10:39 AM | #10 |
Literacy = Understanding
Posts: 4,833
Karma: 59674358
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: The World of Books
Device: Nook, Nook Tablet
|
I notice the fragments but what bothers me even more than the fragments is treating a person as an inanimate object. I always pause over phrases such as "She was the one that had let them down. . ."; in my book, it should be "She was the one who had let them down. . . ."
If it is in character speak, I find it less bothersome -- after all, people often use that when they mean who -- but when it is not in character speak, I don't like it. |
10-27-2010, 10:43 AM | #11 |
Enthusiast
Posts: 29
Karma: 40000
Join Date: Oct 2010
Location: Glendale, CA
Device: Kindle
|
I have used sentence fragments to show that a character's thoughts are jumbled, or the character is in shock. It can be effective, but you have to follow the rules most of the time so breaking them is effective.
|
10-27-2010, 10:54 AM | #12 | |
WWHALD
Posts: 7,879
Karma: 337114
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Mitcham, Surrey, UK
Device: iPad. Selling my silver 505 here
|
Quote:
And the third paragraph uses lighted instead of lit (in reference to another thread ) |
|
10-27-2010, 10:56 AM | #13 |
eBook Enthusiast
Posts: 85,544
Karma: 93383043
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: UK
Device: Kindle Oasis 2, iPad Pro 10.5", iPhone 6
|
It's next on my list of Dickens to be proof-read, so you might want to wait a few weeks and then download it from here. I corrected an error in the PG text that I quoted above: PG says that the fog is "deified", rather than "defiled", in the second paragraph .
|
10-27-2010, 11:01 AM | #14 | |
WWHALD
Posts: 7,879
Karma: 337114
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Mitcham, Surrey, UK
Device: iPad. Selling my silver 505 here
|
Quote:
(And now I can't stop giggling over deified fog) |
|
10-27-2010, 11:06 AM | #15 |
eBook Enthusiast
Posts: 85,544
Karma: 93383043
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: UK
Device: Kindle Oasis 2, iPad Pro 10.5", iPhone 6
|
I must confess that I read the book a couple of times without realising that it was an error; you'll find it in pretty much every "free" version of "Bleak House", since they all seem to use the PG text as source.
|
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Philosophy Kierkegaard, Sören: Philosophical Fragments, v.1, 5 November 2008. | Patricia | Kindle Books (offline) | 1 | 12-27-2011 04:36 PM |
books with cr in the middle of a sentence | p3aul | Calibre | 14 | 06-19-2010 05:09 PM |
Here's to the Dash! Post a Great Sentence! | Lima_dat | Writers' Corner | 3 | 04-25-2009 03:41 AM |
Philosophy Kierkegaard, Sören: Philosophical Fragments, v.1, 5 November 2008. | Patricia | IMP Books (offline) | 0 | 11-05-2008 01:56 PM |
Philosophy Kierkegaard, Sören: Philosophical Fragments, v.1, 5 November 2008. | Patricia | BBeB/LRF Books (offline) | 0 | 11-05-2008 01:53 PM |