|
|
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
01-20-2014, 01:18 AM | #1 |
Bah, humbug!
Posts: 39,073
Karma: 157049943
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: Chesapeake, VA, USA
Device: Kindle Oasis, iPad Pro, & a Samsung Galaxy S9.
|
Book Club January 2014 Discussion: All Quiet on the Western Front
The time has come to discuss the January 2014 MobileRead Book Club selection, All Quiet on the Western Front by Erich Maria Remarque. What did you think?
Last edited by WT Sharpe; 01-24-2014 at 07:27 PM. |
01-20-2014, 10:52 AM | #2 | |
languorous autodidact ✦
Posts: 4,235
Karma: 44637926
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: smiling with the rising sun
Device: onyx boox poke 2 colour, kindle voyage
|
I really liked it. The story is told simply and is short, but it's powerful and philosophic and packs in a poetic punch. I'm not big on war stories but I liked this one mainly because of the beautiful and melancholic poetic nature of some of the passages and also because the descriptions were very vivid. I liked how it interspersed scenes of terrible war and violence with scenes of relaxation and beauty. Here's a short passage that I liked:
Quote:
|
|
Advert | |
|
01-20-2014, 02:55 PM | #3 |
Wizard
Posts: 1,368
Karma: 26886344
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: Ireland
Device: Kindle Oasis 3, 4G, iPad Air 2, iPhone IE
|
This book is even more powerful than the film--and that film is one of the greatest war films ever made But then this is perhaps the greatest Anti-War novel in European Literature. I read the older standard translation by A.W. Wheen done in 1929. In 1993 Brian Murdoch published a new translation and I toyed with getting it. But after reading a number of quite mixed reviews, I decided to stick with the older version as it has stood the test of time.
All Quiet . . . is a devastating attack on the glory of fighting for the "honour" of one's country. It is filled with horror and soul-destroying events. It is also filled with compassion for the innocent young lives that were sacrificed on this terrible altar of blood. Yet there is a kind of consolation. Even in this cauldron it is possible for true heroism to exist--the heroism of validating the self--not through blood-letting but through a recognition of the falsehood of a mirage of glory. Wilfred Owen put this recognition powerfully: "My friend, you would not tell with such high zest To children ardent for some desperate glory, The old Lie; Dulce et Decorum est Pro patria mori." |
01-20-2014, 03:13 PM | #4 |
Guru
Posts: 820
Karma: 8820388
Join Date: Dec 2008
Device: Sony PRS-505, -350; Kindle 3 3G, DX, PW 2; various tablets
|
I also really liked it. Although it was fiction, it seemed to be a realistic portrayal of war to me. Not that I've ever fought in a war, but I have been close to a couple of men who did, and the craziness of the day-to-day existence and fighting seemed to match their stories (including one similar story of a friend who fought in the Battle of the Bulge and got separated from his command, and was eventually picked up and carried back like a king on top of a mattress).
The realism of emotions also struck me, like with his mother and his comrades. Real, and almost too wise and too admitting of human weakness to be done by someone so young. But I think this was the best way to tell the story, related as the incremental learnings and adaptations of a young man in war. Some very minor things that I noticed (with page numbers of the Little Brown hardcover edition): P. 72 When talking about why he might stay in the army and giving its good points: "In the army in peace-time you've nothing to trouble about," he [Haie] goes on, "your food's found every day, or else you kick up a row; you've a bed, every week clean under-wear like a perfect gent, you to your non-com.'s duty, you have a good suit of clothes; in the evening you're a free man and go off to the pub." If that means one pair per week of clean underwear, and it's worth listing as a benefit? Yikes, we've got it good! I recall this being a classic when I was in the lower grades of school, yet with subjects that today might be cause for censorship (p. 153 fart, p. 174 masturbation) in some places in the U.S. (Texas, Arizona, ...). I hope I'm wrong on that. Thanks, Book Club voters. I never would have thought to read this book. |
01-20-2014, 03:39 PM | #5 | |
languorous autodidact ✦
Posts: 4,235
Karma: 44637926
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: smiling with the rising sun
Device: onyx boox poke 2 colour, kindle voyage
|
Quote:
Ditto. I had toyed with reading it years ago since it was never required of me, but didn't. And I wouldn't have anytime soon either without the book club since I've already seen the film, but I'm glad I did. |
|
Advert | |
|
01-20-2014, 06:05 PM | #6 | |||||
Nameless Being
|
I also read the Wheen translation, the one I've had since first reading it in high school about 40 years ago. This must be at least the fifth time I have read it, and as others have said it remains one of the best indictments of patriotic and military madness ever.
I've always been struck by the episode where Bäumer stabs the French soldier who stumbles into the crater that Bäumer has crawled into to take cover in the middle of the battle field. Alone there Bäumer briefly recovers his humanity as he first tries to save the French man's life, then resolves to write his wife telling her of his death, and then resolves: Quote:
This quote about how Bäumer and his young comrades have been forever altered always gets to me as well: Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Kamikaze Diaries Reveal That Many Pilots were Coerced. Quote:
|
|||||
01-21-2014, 12:45 AM | #7 |
Bah, humbug!
Posts: 39,073
Karma: 157049943
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: Chesapeake, VA, USA
Device: Kindle Oasis, iPad Pro, & a Samsung Galaxy S9.
|
It had been years since I watched the movie, and I'd never read the book before this month, so today I rented the movie on my iPad from Google Play and watched it again on my TV via Google Chromecast. Renting movies in this manner is a brand new thing for the Chromecast device; unless I'm mistaken, it's only in the past week that you could rent and/or buy movies from GooglePlay to watch on an iPad (or broadcast them to your TV from your iPad if you have the Chromecast device plugged into your TV).
But that bit of tech announcement aside, I was amazed at how faithfully the 1930 movie followed the book. So much of the dialog was word for word, and so much of the action was scene for scene. I can't think of another book whose screen adaptation has more accurately followed the author's intention. Even details such as the men choosing their spades over their bayonets for hand to hand combat was not overlooked, although the reasons spades were preferred was not given in the movie. That being said, I did feel the movie failed to give the full impact of the book; perhaps because books are simply better mediums to express the inner thoughts and feelings of their characters than are movies, and perhaps also to a lesser degree because books are not limited to the same time constraints as movies. |
01-21-2014, 09:20 AM | #8 |
Bah, humbug!
Posts: 39,073
Karma: 157049943
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: Chesapeake, VA, USA
Device: Kindle Oasis, iPad Pro, & a Samsung Galaxy S9.
|
I think this book should be required reading for everyone on the planet. It certainly takes the glory and romance out of war.
|
02-08-2014, 07:04 AM | #9 | |
Cruiser
Posts: 525
Karma: 1157886
Join Date: Mar 2013
Location: on a small yacht!
Device: kobo glo, samsung galaxy tab note
|
Quote:
I think that anything that makes the reader/viewer remember that all humans are equal and deserve the same respect and consideration should be compulsory reading. Another such book that had a similar impact on me was Roots by Alex Haley. |
|
02-08-2014, 10:18 AM | #10 |
E-reader Enthusiast
Posts: 4,871
Karma: 36507503
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: Southwest, USA
Device: Kindle Oasis 3; Kobo Aura One; iPad Mini 5
|
I think it is easy to identify with the German soldiers, even without military training. It is part of what makes this book so thought-provoking and why it sold 2.5 million copies in 22 languages in its first 18 months. The issues of mortality, patriotism, identity, etc that Paul and his fellow soldiers struggle with are universal. You can easily imagine the the British and French soldiers on the other side of the trenches having similar discussions and dealing with similar emotions. You can see it in how Paul deals with killing the French soldier who appears in his hole in no man's land. You can also see it in how Paul reacts to the Russian prisoners of war when he goes on leave back home & to training. The scenes with the Russians about music and about wanting to share his food were very touching to me. The reader relates to Paul and doesn't see him as a heartless monster. They are fighting, killing, and surviving with animal instincts in the name of their country due to decisions made by a small number of people many levels higher so far removed from them. Yet they are humans with their own individual lives and families and hopes and dreams for the future that have been destroyed by the war. This book was banned and burned in Nazi Germany because of the anti-war questions it raised, especially about patriotic propaganda in the name of the Fatherland.
|
02-09-2014, 09:19 AM | #11 |
o saeclum infacetum
Posts: 20,229
Karma: 222235366
Join Date: Oct 2010
Location: New England
Device: H2O, Aura One, PW5
|
I'm going to be contrarian and say that AQotWF didn't hold up to my memory of it. I've read a lot of Great War literature and there are many first-person and quasi-first person accounts with greater insight and of higher literary quality. This worked as the thoughts of a not-very-well-educated nineteen-year old, but the verisimilitude made it far less compelling to me than the accounts of the officer class. And the end was just cheesy. Remarque had it both ways; a first-person account would end either abruptly with the obvious inference or with the narrator having survived, but Remarque had to go for the final tug at the heartstrings with the third person ending. It would have been better just to stop.
Last edited by issybird; 02-09-2014 at 09:22 AM. |
02-09-2014, 08:50 PM | #12 |
Indie Advocate
Posts: 2,863
Karma: 18794463
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Melbourne, Australia
Device: Kindle
|
I'm with issybird on the ending. I thought it fell utterly flat. However, up until that point I enjoyed it.
What I found quite interesting was that it was very familiar to me. I've neither read the book nor seen the film before, but so much of this I felt like I had read (or seen) before. It might be a testament to how influential the book was on other works - or that it was remarkably accurate and therefore naturally echoes throughout other similar pieces. It might be a bit contentious, but one of the things that I liked about the book wasn't necessarily the "anti-war" sentiment, but the demonstration that in this war, a lot of the bullshit was actually stripped away. That civilisation, feelings of superiority, justifications are the luxuries of those who don't experience the reality of the life-and-death struggles of the front line. There is not only a feeling of comradeship with the enemy, but a recognition of the more primal aspects - that man is just another animal. Sometimes, in my own contemplations, I wonder which aspect is better. Once you've dealt with the animal too long, it's probably difficult to exist in civilisation and the author brings this up a great many times, but from a very specific point of view (that of a certain age). But it is as a civilisation that we can justify war. In the book it is only too obvious that as the individual devolves towards the animal, the killing is accepted, but not really understood. I did find the book a little on the heavy-handed side. It certainly gave the message power. But sometimes I felt that it became a little repetitive - especially the author's contemplations. They seemed to be like a chorus for this ballad and although that's not necessarily a bad thing, it still felt a little overplayed to me. Anyway, I'm glad that I finally had a chance to read this book. In high school, several classes studied this book, but I was not in one of them. I can't remember what we studied instead - but in that year level I remember the books to have been particularly good - To Kill a Mockingbird, Lord of the Flies - so I didn't exactly miss out. I actually managed to get a copy of the book just last week from a friend who had two copies, along with several Steinbacks and a Hemmingway - Score!! |
02-11-2014, 10:49 AM | #13 | |||
Nameless Being
|
Quote:
Great comments from our resident expert on books about WWI. That said I will make some contrarian comments to the contrarian. I actually like that the story was told from the point of view of young enlisted private instead of from that of an officer. In large part because in Europe at that time the division between officers and privates would have reflected the economic and social class stratification in the peace time countries. I agree with you about then ending. Perhaps Remarque was a little at a loss about how to best wrap the story up? I've heard literary critics say similar things about Mark Twain and the ending of The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn. In my opinion it might have been better to just end AQotWF with the end of chapter XI: Quote:
or to make Chapter XII the final chapter, but omit the final two paragraphs of that. Quote:
Last edited by Hamlet53; 02-11-2014 at 11:18 AM. |
|||
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
MobileRead Book Club August 2013 Discussion: Doomsday Book by Connie Willis (spoilers) | WT Sharpe | Book Clubs | 31 | 06-15-2017 05:39 PM |
Free and bargain romance ebooks + Discussion January 2014 | library addict | Deals and Resources (No Self-Promotion or Affiliate Links) | 563 | 02-01-2014 10:08 AM |
MobileRead January 2014 Book Club (non) Nominations | WT Sharpe | Book Clubs | 15 | 12-26-2013 02:48 PM |
MobileRead [Big OPPS!] January 2014 Book Club Nominations [Big OPPS!] | WT Sharpe | Book Clubs | 8 | 12-20-2013 05:39 PM |
Literary The MobileRead Literary Book Club September 2011 Discussion: Unbroken | sun surfer | Book Clubs | 12 | 10-14-2011 04:24 PM |