Why HarryT doesnt freak out and Granny Does!!!

[GeoffC]

Originally Posted by columbus

...... to your religious beliefs or otherwise - reincarnation?

mmmm..... poll fodder growing here ....

[columbus]

Originally Posted by GeoffC;

mmmm..... poll fodder growing here ....

Your turn

[GeoffC]

Originally Posted by columbus

Your turn

oh - no no no no no - i'm no way qualified enough to start one - i mean - think of all the options not including blue ones, otter ones and others ..... :shudders:

[columbus]

Originally Posted by GeoffC;

oh - no no no no no - i'm no way qualified enough to start one - i mean - think of all the options not including blue ones, otter ones and others ..... :shudders:

and udders ..... :shudders

[vivaldirules]

(Doggie watches kitty and squirrel converse about otters and such. Curious!)

[benham]

Well that's just plain mousy!

[columbus]

Originally Posted by benham;

Well that's just plain mousy!

Cat food!

[Abelturd]

This is a great thread. It's so much more fun to read posts that ooze with emotions, either positive or negative, where people choose sides, where tensions escalate. Very refreshing. So far I've been ignoring the LOTR thread, but now I'm looking forward to reading it.

[kazbates]

Originally Posted by hidari

WHat is the point. Yes I have a brain. Yes, I am sure most think I do not use it at MR. Look. I stirred the pot. I think the criticism is good .... of me or whoever. but what is the point. I said a thing or two and now... The "knowledgeable" ones tell me the CORRECT answer. Now. Does that make you happier?

I have responded. As Bertold Told me. I am Wrong.....YOU are right. Enjoy.

Hidari, Criticism is good, when it's meant to be constructive and presented in a positive way. Criticism just for the sake of it, is never good. The same can be said for "stirring the pot." True debate on a topic is a wonderful thing. It helps all sides of an argument (and I don't use argument in it's common usage in regards to hostilities between people) express their ideas for further clarification. Ricky is absolutely correct. People have all kinds of opinions. Some I agree with and some I don't. Agreeing with everyone would be counterproductive. But, understanding what is behind their opinions helps expand our humanity and our view of the world. I personally would hate to live in a world where opinions were limited to only those with which I agree.
There have been many threads where I have not agreed with other posters, but the majority of people with whom I disagreed responded in a friendly non-combative manner which furthered the discussion and helped clarify their point of view. Did I change my view, most likely not, but I gained a more rounded perspective. On the other hand, I did not post to your Lord of the Rings thread predominantly because of the aggressive wording of your original post. Taking an antagonistic approach to a debate adds nothing but hard feelings and is, once again, counterproductive to the discussion. If you want to start a thread to discuss a topic about which you feel strongly, please do so. Just remember to state your opinion clearly, concisely, and with out angst. You will get a great deal more responses and a much more fulfilling debate.

[wodin]

Might it have something to do with being or not being British??

[astra]

Originally Posted by wodin

Might it have something to do with being or not being British??

[columbus]

Sadly Kas, I fear your thoughtful and cogent comment will pass well over the head of this particular individual. Posting as they are with multiple identities.

Perhaps the best solution is to continue treating this thread with the light-hearted contempt shown by previous posters.

[Abelturd]

Contempt it is, then.

[benham]

Originally Posted by columbus

Perhaps the best solution is to continue treating this thread with the light-hearted contempt shown by previous posters.

I never drink Light if it can be avoided. Especially Bud Light. Is that evn a beer?

[Steven Lyle Jordan]

Someone please tell me that this thread wasn't started, and hasn't lasted this long, over an argument about the Lord of Those Silly Flippin' Rings?!?