11-17-2020, 01:10 PM | #16 |
Wizard
Posts: 4,461
Karma: 429063498
Join Date: Aug 2014
Location: Mauritius
Device: Kindle Paperwhite 4
|
|
11-17-2020, 07:44 PM | #17 |
cacoethes scribendi
Posts: 5,811
Karma: 137770742
Join Date: Nov 2010
Location: Australia
Device: Kobo Aura One & H2Ov2, Sony PRS-650
|
Mandate? No. But the exercise feels pointless to me because I found the two quite different to read (both quintessentially their own place and time), and so liking or disliking one is not going to be an indicator for liking or disliking the other - which seems to me to be the main/most-useful reason for making such comparisons.
|
Advert | |
|
11-17-2020, 07:56 PM | #18 | |
Diligent dilettante
Posts: 3,440
Karma: 49052774
Join Date: Sep 2019
Location: in my mind
Device: Kobo Sage; Kobo Libra H2O
|
Quote:
|
|
11-18-2020, 02:39 AM | #19 | |
Wizard
Posts: 4,461
Karma: 429063498
Join Date: Aug 2014
Location: Mauritius
Device: Kindle Paperwhite 4
|
Quote:
|
|
11-18-2020, 03:12 AM | #20 | |
Diligent dilettante
Posts: 3,440
Karma: 49052774
Join Date: Sep 2019
Location: in my mind
Device: Kobo Sage; Kobo Libra H2O
|
Quote:
Of course LotR and the Hobbit are very similar, they're by the same author and the similarities are intentional. and commented on at length BY the author himself. That's NOT comparing apples to oranges, and is not a valid argument in defence of comparing dissimilar works like those of Penny and Christie |
|
Advert | |
|
11-18-2020, 03:42 AM | #21 |
Wizard
Posts: 4,461
Karma: 429063498
Join Date: Aug 2014
Location: Mauritius
Device: Kindle Paperwhite 4
|
My intent with this example was to show that there's more that meets the eye in these books, just as it is between apple and orange books. Many readers who have read the interviews of Tolkien himself don't know to what depth the two books are similar. This bizarrely pounced upon quote doesn't negate my opinion that one can compare books from different authors. I compare all of the time. Does that makes my comparison invalid? Why?
|
11-18-2020, 05:22 AM | #22 |
cacoethes scribendi
Posts: 5,811
Karma: 137770742
Join Date: Nov 2010
Location: Australia
Device: Kobo Aura One & H2Ov2, Sony PRS-650
|
As I said, no mandate from me. Even my "point trying to compare" is a comparison of sorts.
|
11-18-2020, 08:05 AM | #23 |
Resident Curmudgeon
Posts: 75,862
Karma: 134368292
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Roslindale, Massachusetts
Device: Kobo Libra 2, Kobo Aura H2O, PRS-650, PRS-T1, nook STR, PW3
|
|
11-18-2020, 09:12 AM | #24 |
o saeclum infacetum
Posts: 20,539
Karma: 224837692
Join Date: Oct 2010
Location: New England
Device: H2O, Aura One, PW5
|
I did think of St. Mary Mead, but I had to look up the other two. I saw the first season of Father Brown and liked it very much indeed, but didn’t remember the name of the village. I must say that this tv iteration of Father Brown has nothing in common with the Chesterton original. Even on looking up Saint-Marie, I’ve never heard of the show, but I think the New Englandy aspect of Stars Hollow and Cabot Cove are probably closer to the feel of Three Pines than the Caribbean, even if the body count is similar.
|
11-18-2020, 09:58 AM | #25 | |
Resident Curmudgeon
Posts: 75,862
Karma: 134368292
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Roslindale, Massachusetts
Device: Kobo Libra 2, Kobo Aura H2O, PRS-650, PRS-T1, nook STR, PW3
|
Quote:
One more small town is Lochdubh. |
|
11-18-2020, 03:44 PM | #26 |
Wizard
Posts: 1,375
Karma: 26915798
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: Ireland
Device: Kindle Oasis 3, 4G, iPad Air 2, iPhone IE
|
I found the book tiresome. As a mystery it never seemed to catch fire for me.
There was a clever use of an Mathew 10:36 as a kind of recurring theme and Gamache was a reasonably interesting character. But that was about it for me. |
11-19-2020, 04:18 PM | #27 |
Wizard
Posts: 1,015
Karma: 19767610
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Nova Scotia Canada
Device: ipad, Kindle PW, Kobo Clara; iphone 7
|
I just finished the book. I’m sorry I didn’t join the discussion earlier. I started reading late, and have been avoiding the thread, in case it held spoilers. As it happens, it doesn’t, and I’ve enjoyed reading everyone’s take on it. Quite divergent opinions.
I enjoyed the book, primarily because I liked Garmache as a leading character, and enjoyed seeing his regular team in action. Plus, I found the mystery interesting, though guessed a few things ahead of time. I thought it was well crafted. I also really enjoyed the little references to Québécois food and culture. That said, I would have dropped this book part way through the first chapter, if not for the bookclub. I found the writing painful and distracting. It was overwritten, and seemed like an unedited first draft. To me, the setting wasn’t too twee, but the character descriptions and their activities certainly were. Plus there was too much trembling, quivering, and obvious red herrings. I just wanted to grab a pen or give up. But surprisingly, as soon as Garmache was introduced in the second chapter, the writing became much crisper, and the characters more believable. Instead of wanting to edit, I found myself engaged by the story and kept reading. So I’m pleased I kept going, and will try another book in the series. I won’t know until I try another book, but I suspect Penny’s inexperience was chiefly to blame for the first chapter. What’s puzzling is that a good editor could easily have helped with revisions. In terms of other comments, I don’t see the similarity between this book and golden age fiction. The Eastern Townships are next door to Cabot Cove, but I didn’t find that off-putting. However, Three Pines is such a small village, that I can’t see how one could shoehorn another murderer in there, let alone a whole series of them. At least Christie gave herself a whole island to work with, so I’m definitely curious as to how Penny can pull it off Last edited by Victoria; 11-19-2020 at 04:23 PM. |
11-19-2020, 04:22 PM | #28 |
Resident Curmudgeon
Posts: 75,862
Karma: 134368292
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Roslindale, Massachusetts
Device: Kobo Libra 2, Kobo Aura H2O, PRS-650, PRS-T1, nook STR, PW3
|
I've not yet finished the book, but even if I wasn't reading for the bookclub, I would have not stopped at chapter 1. I'd have given it at least 3 chapters. So far it's working for me.
|
11-19-2020, 04:48 PM | #29 |
Wizard
Posts: 3,007
Karma: 18401861
Join Date: Oct 2010
Location: Sudbury, ON, Canada
Device: PRS-505, PB 902, PRS-T1, PB 623, PB 840, PB 633
|
It's been years since I read this book, so my memories are a bit hazy. It was the first Louise Penny book I had ever read. I thought it was okay, but something put me off Gamache a little bit. I read another in the series, and finally figured out what was bugging me. I'm sure the women here have read many books where the male author wrote female characters that were idealizations of what he desired. In this case, the shoe was on the other foot (I am a male), and I found Gamache to be irritatingly perfect in a way that I imagined a female would desire. He just didn't seem like a real male character to me. So, I didn't read any more books in the series after that. Maybe I didn't like seeing how "wrong" my traits were compared to Gamache's.
I'm not proud of my reaction to the books, but I thought I'd bring it up to see if it generated any discussion here. Maybe something good will come of it. |
11-19-2020, 07:02 PM | #30 | |
Wizard
Posts: 1,015
Karma: 19767610
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Nova Scotia Canada
Device: ipad, Kindle PW, Kobo Clara; iphone 7
|
Quote:
That said, reading about idealized people & settings can be a pleasure sometimes too. A nice change from politics. |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Louise Penny - Three Time Agatha Award Winner | SensualPoet | Reading Recommendations | 45 | 12-18-2011 01:29 PM |
Louise Penny, newest book | Strayer | Reading Recommendations | 3 | 09-05-2011 10:19 AM |
Why I'll never give another penny to Waterstones | omk3 | News | 31 | 02-24-2010 02:00 PM |
The Caliphate - a penny | MichaelFStewart | Deals and Resources (No Self-Promotion or Affiliate Links) | 0 | 01-25-2010 09:45 AM |