Will you buy the Kindle 3G or Kindle WiFi? - Page 3

osnova · 07-29-2010, 06:10 PM

I've ordered wifi-only (I already have the original DX). My phone n900's 3G can be shared through a hotspot application. So, I am covered.

Quake1028 · 07-29-2010, 07:03 PM

I ordered the WiFi version. I don't travel much, at all, and have tons of books that need to be read loaded on my machine, so I never have that "gotta have it right this second" feeling. Plus $50 can go towards more books.

texasnightowl · 07-29-2010, 07:08 PM

Well, the version in my cart is the WiFi. I don't travel much, have hundreds of unread books I can load onto it from Calibre, and I normally keep the wireless off and shop from the website and then at some point, at home, deliberately turn on wireless to download purchases - usually when I'm ready to do a dedrm and calibre import session. So the WiFi version will suit me just fine. I'm just trying to convince myself to go for it when my K1 still works fine...though I do have at least 2 people interested in purchasing it if I do upgrade.

scveteran · 07-29-2010, 07:28 PM

Wi-Fi is the way to go for me since I never leave my house.

matt314159 · 07-29-2010, 07:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by osnova

My phone n900's 3G can be shared through a hotspot application. So, I am covered.

My Touch Pro 2 also does mobile hotspot, but IIRC, they said on amazon that the K3 can't connect through peer-to-peer/ad-hoc connections, which are what the mobile hotspot applications typically consist of. I've never seen a mobile wifi router application for smartphones that emulates a full router, it's always an ad-hoc connection.

Mirtika · 07-29-2010, 07:41 PM

I put both the wifi and wifi 3g in my "saved section" at amazon while I think about which one I should get. I'm leaning toward the 3g K3 with wi fi, honestly, but the truth is I probably will be buying books at home where I already have wireless, and all the McDonald's and Starbucks stores in my area are AT&T hot spots, so if I just HAVE TO HAVE IT, I can pop in to one of those (or the B&Ns, which would be tacky...but yeah, an option, too).

Do I want to spend the $50. I don't know.

I have had the Sony PRS 505 for a few years, and I'm really MORE tempted by the larger Kindle DXG, cause I have middle-aged crappy eyes...and the idea of making the font size, like, 20, appeals. But that price point IS NOT appealing

Anyone who uses reading glasses (at around 200 to 250)...can you read on the regular Kindle just fine without the specs?

Anyway, we are definitely gonna get an iPad (hubby is a software engineer and we both sort of went a wee bit gaga when we tested it in store) when the 2nd gen comes out--our mantra re Apple, ALWAYS WAIT FOR THE 2nD GEN!-- and that will be for an assortment of uses, but I want somethng JUST FOR my reading I'm allergic to all my glasses --had Lasik which helped--but still need them to read and have had to cut down reading time or read on the computer (not ideal), so the Kindle is really calling me.

Well, whatever. I'm just so confused given these price drops, what may be coming, and if they might come with a Kindle DXG with wi fi and a lower price that would really suit me better, maybe (unless I get tired holding it).

So, likely 3g Wi Fi Kindle3, Graphite...with a red cover to go with my 8 dozen assorted red lipsticks, natch.

Geez, do I ramble...

estrial · 07-29-2010, 08:10 PM

3g+wifi for myself too.. internet not as easily available for me when I travel around to "rural" area but the kindle2 3g worked swell. wifi is just a plus for when im in the city usage even though I would have been happy with 3g and blue tooth instead of 3g+wifi

and a pink light cover *squees*

Pushka · 07-29-2010, 08:10 PM

wifi. But just thinking about this, I wonder updates will be delivered. Given the debacle over the 2.5 update, will we have to wait for Amazon to put it on their website?

BobLenx · 07-29-2010, 09:38 PM

Went for the WiFi version with a burnt orange basic cover. I spend winters in FL and summers in NY and the Spring WhisperNet in both places with my K2US rots. I have super fantastic WiFi in both FL and NY so savee the extra 50 bucks (paid for the cover shipping and tax).

Spent the day updating the metadata for all the eBooks on my laptop to be ready. Takes time to clean it all up properly. Such a pain to have an authors listed as FIRST LAST - LAST FIRST - LAST, FIRST - it is messy.

sprise · 07-29-2010, 11:09 PM

I went with the wi-fi only version, as well. I have a wireless network at home, and always have enough books loaded on the reader at any given time that running out isn't an issue. I only use the 3G on my current Kindle to download samples, but even just turning it on ocassionally I've noticed it's nowhere near as reliable as my wireless service is.

matt314159 · 07-30-2010, 12:01 AM

I'm just curious about this: 3G is a $50 hardware premium, which is a very fair price if I thought I'd use it. I understand the older firmwares on the k2 could browse the web for like, basic facebook and blog-reading, but later that was disabled, is that correct?

With the k3, would 3g have any potential benefit aside from buying books wirelessly? Would the webkit browser have any hope of ever working over 3g (hacks, etc?) ??

If I thought the 3g would let me hope onto facebook and browse, and do simple email, I'd cancel the wifi preorder and go for the 3g graphite instead. But it seems like they're moving in the direction of limiting what you can do via whispernet, am I correct?

AnemicOak · 07-30-2010, 12:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by matt314159

I'm just curious about this: 3G is a $50 hardware premium, which is a very fair price if I thought I'd use it. I understand the older firmwares on the k2 could browse the web for like, basic facebook and blog-reading, but later that was disabled, is that correct?

With the k3, would 3g have any potential benefit aside from buying books wirelessly? Would the webkit browser have any hope of ever working over 3g (hacks, etc?) ??

If I thought the 3g would let me hope onto facebook and browse, and do simple email, I'd cancel the wifi preorder and go for the 3g graphite instead. But it seems like they're moving in the direction of limiting what you can do via whispernet, am I correct?

The K2 has always been able to browse using 3G in the US. What happened was it got enabled for most countries in the latest big upgrade (2.5) and then there was a minor upgrade that disabled it for some countries. I assume enabling it was a mistake as letting folks browse where Amazon doesn't have contracts with cell providers (like the US and UK) got pretty expensive in paying roaming charges. So the browsing on the K3 is limited to WiFi depending on where you are and if they have an actual contract with a cell provider (US and UK are all I know of). At least that's how I understand things.

matt314159 · 07-30-2010, 12:21 AM

so...there's a chance the k3 might work for internet via 3g in the US, w/o even needing to tweak/hack/sneak anything? This might change my mind and make me go for the 3g instead. Browsing the web on my cell phone (even though it's a 3.6" screen) is a pain, and usually all I need are facebook/gmail/blogs/vbulletin or phpbb forums. I can see that being very handy, indeed.

Thanks for the patience with the newbie question and for setting me straight. I've not followed the kindle much at all, so it's all new to me. I might be tempted to get the k3 3g, but what worried me was that it said that the webkit worked only via wifi.

AnemicOak · 07-30-2010, 12:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by matt314159

so...there's a chance the k3 might work for internet via 3g in the US, w/o even needing to tweak/hack/sneak anything? This might change my mind and make me go for the 3g instead. Browsing the web on my cell phone (even though it's a 3.6" screen) is a pain, and usually all I need are facebook/gmail/blogs/vbulletin or phpbb forums. I can see that being very handy, indeed.

Thanks for the patience with the newbie question and for setting me straight. I've not followed the kindle much at all, so it's all new to me. I might be tempted to get the k3 3g, but what worried me was that it said that the webkit worked only via wifi.

The K3 WILL work for browsing via 3G in the US and UK (it mentions it right on the product page for both), I don't know about elsewhere, but have seen some areas are limited to WiFi for using the browser.

matt314159 · 07-30-2010, 12:36 AM

*smacks head*...I need to check the product page again, because I saw this:

Quote:

New WebKit-Based Browser – Browse the web over Wi-Fi (experimental)

and assumed that was their subtle way of saying [but not 3g]

I'm going to the product page again, and if I see it with my own two eyes (not doubting you at all, just want to make sure....trust but verify

) I'm going to cancel my wifi preorder and change it to the graphite 3g.

Again, thanks for straightening me out! You look like you need more karma so I'm sending some your way

*eta - I'm the world's biggest goober, I had clicked through to the wifi version on the home page, which is why it only said wifi. On the 3g version's page:

Quote:

New WebKit-Based Browser – Free 3G web browsing (experimental)

*edit2 -Preorder changed. Thanks again!

View Poll Results: Kindle 3 Wi-Fi or 3G+WiFi?
Wi-Fi Only	205	53.11%
Wi-Fi+3G	181	46.89%
Voters: 386. You may not vote on this poll

07-29-2010, 07:41 PM	#36
Mirtika Member Posts: 23 Karma: 14 Join Date: Nov 2007 Location: Miami, FL Device: Sony Reader PRS505	I put both the wifi and wifi 3g in my "saved section" at amazon while I think about which one I should get. I'm leaning toward the 3g K3 with wi fi, honestly, but the truth is I probably will be buying books at home where I already have wireless, and all the McDonald's and Starbucks stores in my area are AT&T hot spots, so if I just HAVE TO HAVE IT, I can pop in to one of those (or the B&Ns, which would be tacky...but yeah, an option, too). Do I want to spend the $50. I don't know. I have had the Sony PRS 505 for a few years, and I'm really MORE tempted by the larger Kindle DXG, cause I have middle-aged crappy eyes...and the idea of making the font size, like, 20, appeals. But that price point IS NOT appealing Anyone who uses reading glasses (at around 200 to 250)...can you read on the regular Kindle just fine without the specs? Anyway, we are definitely gonna get an iPad (hubby is a software engineer and we both sort of went a wee bit gaga when we tested it in store) when the 2nd gen comes out--our mantra re Apple, ALWAYS WAIT FOR THE 2nD GEN!-- and that will be for an assortment of uses, but I want somethng JUST FOR my reading I'm allergic to all my glasses --had Lasik which helped--but still need them to read and have had to cut down reading time or read on the computer (not ideal), so the Kindle is really calling me. Well, whatever. I'm just so confused given these price drops, what may be coming, and if they might come with a Kindle DXG with wi fi and a lower price that would really suit me better, maybe (unless I get tired holding it). So, likely 3g Wi Fi Kindle3, Graphite...with a red cover to go with my 8 dozen assorted red lipsticks, natch. Geez, do I ramble... Last edited by Mirtika; 07-29-2010 at 07:48 PM.

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Kindle to Israel, WIFI or WIFI+3G?	shemsha	Amazon Kindle	15	05-06-2011 03:12 PM
Mails to @kindle.com with the Kindle 3 wifi only?	guiyoforward	Amazon Kindle	13	10-12-2010 12:02 AM
Buy nook wifi/kindle wifi	nelson7lim	Flea Market	1	08-15-2010 05:32 PM
NOOK wifi? or KINDLE 3 wifi?	nelson7lim	Which one should I buy?	28	08-15-2010 11:38 AM
New Kindle WiFi showing up in my Manage Your Kindle account	jswinden	Amazon Kindle	6	07-31-2010 12:49 AM

07-29-2010, 06:10 PM	#31
osnova Kindler of the Flame Posts: 582 Karma: 646016 Join Date: Oct 2009 Location: US of A Device: K DX,3,KT,KP,KF, KFHD; Nook C, PRS600, iPad, Xoom, N900, N810, Zaurus	I've ordered wifi-only (I already have the original DX). My phone n900's 3G can be shared through a hotspot application. So, I am covered.

07-29-2010, 07:03 PM	#32
Quake1028 Guru Posts: 917 Karma: 9155462 Join Date: Jul 2010 Location: Tampa, FL Device: See signature	I ordered the WiFi version. I don't travel much, at all, and have tons of books that need to be read loaded on my machine, so I never have that "gotta have it right this second" feeling. Plus $50 can go towards more books.

07-29-2010, 07:08 PM	#33
texasnightowl Guru Posts: 812 Karma: 2873645 Join Date: Jul 2008 Location: Texas Device: PW5, Oasis 3, K4B(NT), K3/KK	Well, the version in my cart is the WiFi. I don't travel much, have hundreds of unread books I can load onto it from Calibre, and I normally keep the wireless off and shop from the website and then at some point, at home, deliberately turn on wireless to download purchases - usually when I'm ready to do a dedrm and calibre import session. So the WiFi version will suit me just fine. I'm just trying to convince myself to go for it when my K1 still works fine...though I do have at least 2 people interested in purchasing it if I do upgrade.

07-29-2010, 07:28 PM	#34
scveteran Groupie Posts: 162 Karma: 1230 Join Date: Mar 2009 Device: none	Wi-Fi is the way to go for me since I never leave my house.

07-29-2010, 08:10 PM	#37
estrial small is good Posts: 95 Karma: 100 Join Date: Jul 2010 Location: Australia Device: Kindle 3, Samsung Galaxy S	3g+wifi for myself too.. internet not as easily available for me when I travel around to "rural" area but the kindle2 3g worked swell. wifi is just a plus for when im in the city usage even though I would have been happy with 3g and blue tooth instead of 3g+wifi and a pink light cover squees

07-29-2010, 08:10 PM	#38
Pushka Wizard Posts: 1,119 Karma: 1019140 Join Date: Oct 2009 Location: Australia Device: kindle, Ipad, Iphone, Nexus and PPW	wifi. But just thinking about this, I wonder updates will be delivered. Given the debacle over the 2.5 update, will we have to wait for Amazon to put it on their website?

07-29-2010, 09:38 PM	#39
BobLenx Connoisseur Posts: 78 Karma: 308 Join Date: Jan 2008 Device: Sony505 K2 K3	Went for the WiFi version with a burnt orange basic cover. I spend winters in FL and summers in NY and the Spring WhisperNet in both places with my K2US rots. I have super fantastic WiFi in both FL and NY so savee the extra 50 bucks (paid for the cover shipping and tax). Spent the day updating the metadata for all the eBooks on my laptop to be ready. Takes time to clean it all up properly. Such a pain to have an authors listed as FIRST LAST - LAST FIRST - LAST, FIRST - it is messy.

07-29-2010, 11:09 PM	#40
sprise Member Posts: 18 Karma: 10 Join Date: Aug 2009 Location: Maryland Device: Kindle (basic), Kobo Glo	I went with the wi-fi only version, as well. I have a wireless network at home, and always have enough books loaded on the reader at any given time that running out isn't an issue. I only use the 3G on my current Kindle to download samples, but even just turning it on ocassionally I've noticed it's nowhere near as reliable as my wireless service is.

07-30-2010, 12:01 AM	#41
matt314159 Groupie Posts: 198 Karma: 1000 Join Date: Jul 2010 Location: High Desert, SoCal Device: KSO, NookColor (CM7.1), Samsung Mesmerize	I'm just curious about this: 3G is a $50 hardware premium, which is a very fair price if I thought I'd use it. I understand the older firmwares on the k2 could browse the web for like, basic facebook and blog-reading, but later that was disabled, is that correct? With the k3, would 3g have any potential benefit aside from buying books wirelessly? Would the webkit browser have any hope of ever working over 3g (hacks, etc?) ?? If I thought the 3g would let me hope onto facebook and browse, and do simple email, I'd cancel the wifi preorder and go for the 3g graphite instead. But it seems like they're moving in the direction of limiting what you can do via whispernet, am I correct?

07-30-2010, 12:21 AM	#43
matt314159 Groupie Posts: 198 Karma: 1000 Join Date: Jul 2010 Location: High Desert, SoCal Device: KSO, NookColor (CM7.1), Samsung Mesmerize	so...there's a chance the k3 might work for internet via 3g in the US, w/o even needing to tweak/hack/sneak anything? This might change my mind and make me go for the 3g instead. Browsing the web on my cell phone (even though it's a 3.6" screen) is a pain, and usually all I need are facebook/gmail/blogs/vbulletin or phpbb forums. I can see that being very handy, indeed. Thanks for the patience with the newbie question and for setting me straight. I've not followed the kindle much at all, so it's all new to me. I might be tempted to get the k3 3g, but what worried me was that it said that the webkit worked only via wifi.