Quote:
Originally Posted by Bookpossum
For a book about a terrible tragedy with huge loss of life and terrible injuries, flippant remarks such as the one about the cow are at the very least inappropriate.
I can't see The Robe, either book or film, as having any connection whatsoever with Halifax and the explosion.
As for which Prince of Wales it was, the date would be quite a good clue. If someone reading didn't know and wanted to, they could always look it up.
This sort of thing might be okay in a novel, though I would be distinctly put off by such examples. It is not okay in a book claiming to be history, popular or otherwise. There are plenty of good popular histories and I have enjoyed several, as I have an interest in history. This is not one of them.
|
I don't find the cow remark flippant. It just seems to be a way of telling us the family owned a cow.
Citing
The Robe identifies Douglas. What's wrong with that?
I'm glad you know when the various princes of Wales held the title, but I'm a dumb American and I don't. So I appreciate the context.