MobileRead Forums - View Single Post

elementz · 05-20-2011, 09:23 AM

Starson71, I guess your words were a bit too harsh. So, great that you toned it down a bit ;-)
luketheobscure, why so pissed off? Some critics may be harsh, but still, as a designer one needs to be able to live with critique, right? At least thats what I do when I ask for critique of my designs. And UX design really is more than a beautiful UI, especially when it comes down to usability and varying use cases.
If you really have lots of experience in UX, then I believe it would be great if you are willing to share your experience.
Since your design was simply a mockup, how about really starting from the different use cases, ask the community how they really use calibre. What functions are important, which are less important, aso. And then go from there, not the other way around.

And, dude, suck it up, and stop being such a diva.

05-20-2011, 09:23 AM	#27
elementz Member Posts: 19 Karma: 10 Join Date: Dec 2010 Device: kindle	Starson71, I guess your words were a bit too harsh. So, great that you toned it down a bit ;-) luketheobscure, why so pissed off? Some critics may be harsh, but still, as a designer one needs to be able to live with critique, right? At least thats what I do when I ask for critique of my designs. And UX design really is more than a beautiful UI, especially when it comes down to usability and varying use cases. If you really have lots of experience in UX, then I believe it would be great if you are willing to share your experience. Since your design was simply a mockup, how about really starting from the different use cases, ask the community how they really use calibre. What functions are important, which are less important, aso. And then go from there, not the other way around. And, dude, suck it up, and stop being such a diva. Last edited by elementz; 05-20-2011 at 07:22 PM.