Quote:
Originally Posted by jj2me
But for people with some minimal technical skills, Kindle disadvantages 1 and 3 are simple to cure.
Replacing the Kindle's battery is about the easiest feat for a "non-replaceable" battery. It pops in after you remove a few pieces--not even leads to unplug and plug.
ADE support: Google ineptepub. Then Calibre to convert. Follow the spirit of the Library's restrictions (i.e., delete the ebook when it's expired).
People have different needs, and for some, trading a Sony or Kindle for a Nook is not an upgrade, maybe not even a sidegrade. Most Nook owners may see it as an upgrade, but what if one likes full touch? Nook is not an upgrade (keep your Sony). You like quality metal and materials and small form factor? Nook is not an upgrade (keep your Sony). You like Wikipedia and Google Reader and Gmail anywhere? Nook is not an upgrade (keep your Kindle). Etc. You may laugh, but I wouldn't trade my Sony 505 straight up for a Nook. |
I can't argue with your point about replacing the battery because the video you linked to makes it seem easy. However, it does require a screwdriver and minor disassembly. Certainly not as easy as the Nook.
Your point about ADE support is suspect. I suppose it could be said about every ereader in the world that all you have to do is A) Strip the DRM B) Convert in Calibre. C) Erase when you are done. Using this logic, format and store distribution are irrelevant. This process is not as easy as it sounds (and illegal). If you are going to do all that, you might as well just download a pirated copy of the book in a kindle supported format (I don't condone this).
Your points about design, full touch, etc. are all good points because as readers, we all have personal preferences. For example, I would prefer a small color touchscreen over a full eink touchscreen with glare and poor contrast.
Your point about Wikipedia, Google Reader, and Gmail is valid, but I believe the Nook's browser can at least do all of this over wifi, although not everywhere unless it is soft rooted. However, these are features that could be integrated with future firmware updates.
I tried to stay away from minor quibbles in my analysis, because no device is perfect, and all devices have their strengths and weaknesses. For example, I didn't mention the fact that on the Nook you can play Chess and Sodoku anywhere. I think an easy to replace battery, Native support of library books and ADE content, and expandable memory are significant advantages. Some would even include the "Lend Me" option as significant. My old Atari 2600 was probably a more reliable piece of hardware with better construction than an XBOX 360, but I would have a hard time convincing anyone to trade with me!