Quote:
Originally Posted by cian
Which implies
|
No, what you infer from the comment is different to what it implies. I did not imply anything. I wrote something specific.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by cian
that your problem with file-sharing
|
My post and point had nothing to do with any "problem" with file-sharing. Which is why I specifically did not go into any "problem" I may or may not have with it.
My post and point was that the argument put forward by schex86 for why he/she has no problem with file-sharing is completely flawed.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by cian
of files is its illegality, right?
|
Once you take the above two facts into consideration I am sure you will see that the legality or otherwise of file-sharing has nothing to do with my post or point. Therefore whether or not your assertion is "right" is completely irrelevant.
I only mentioned the legality or otherwise of file-sharing as a direct response to and in order to correct your erroneous guess that I would not want to see file-sharing made legal in the future. I only mentioned the legality or otherwise of libraries as a direct response to and in order to correct your erroneous assertion that I would have a problem with libraries if they were made illegal in the future.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by cian
So in a highly unlikely scenario where libraries were no longer licensed/legal/whatever, you would be object to them because of the illegality, right?
|
Taking the above 3 statements of mine into consideration I am sure you will see that your assertion;
a: has nothing whatsoever to do with my post or point;
b: is based on your own assumptions about my attitude towards both file-sharing and libraries and not on anything I have personally posted and;
c: is completely erroneous.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by cian
I'm not trying to trap you, though rereading it I can see that it might seem that way.
|
Whether you were trying to "trap" me or not is beside the point.
What you were doing was misinterpreting my post and point(perhaps my fault for not being clearer), making numerous assumptions and guesses about my attitude towards both file-sharing and libraries and claiming I had made assertions I had not.(all of which is your doing.)
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by cian
Anyway I wasn't trying to piss you off, and we seem to be talking at cross purposes, so I'll drop it. Apologies.
|
You have not pissed me off. I simply don't accept people claiming I am saying something I am not and seek to rectify the misrepresentation whenever it occurs.
Apology accepted.
Cheers,
PKFFW