View Single Post
Old 12-16-2009, 01:57 PM   #59
djloewen
Connoisseur
djloewen began at the beginning.
 
Posts: 52
Karma: 30
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Toronto
Device: Kobo eReader
Quote:
But the margins are from the publisher. ePub looks how it looks based on what the publisher did when making the ePub.
My local library recently acquired two ePub books that my wife had already bought through Sony (Charlaine Harris novels, if anyone cares). Now that Sony has gone ePub I've re-downloaded, and compared the ePubs from the two different sources.

The filesizes are within 1KB of each other. The content looks identical, but the margins/formatting are diffrerent. The epubs from the library (i.e. from Overdrive) have margins that more or less match a physical book - including the cover, which is an "Ace Books, New YorK" Title page with a margin-like border around it. The Sony copy has the exact same title page, but a bit "bigger", i.e. with smaller margins. The inside is the same. Sony's has much smaller margins.

This really bothers me. I would have hoped that an ePub would be the same (made by the publisher) no matter where I bought it from. I do not like that there is a difference between these files, and it makes me wonder how other stores compare. If I had the money I'd like to pick 10 books and buy them from all the available ePub-selling stores, and compare them. If one store was consistenly different from the others, I wouldn't buy from them. Do they all do their own conversion job from something the publisher gives them (maybe HTML)? Are they all a bit different?

Last edited by djloewen; 12-16-2009 at 03:02 PM.
djloewen is offline   Reply With Quote