Somene calling himself "Anonymous" posted a comment to me about my slight editing and rewriting of Alan's original piece, purely as a thought exercise, and he said he liked it, nothing:
"I must say, [Alan's original] piece is immeasurably improved by what you have done [by taking out the Nazi/Holocaust/Jews stuff]. It is at least possible [now] to figure out what Kaufman was driving at ...once one is not seeing red from constantly being accused of being a Nazi.
Minus the insulting "you-are-all-Nazis" verbiage, there are actually some reasonably good points here. Nothing that hasn't been discussed many times at Mobileread, of course, but Kaufman is very new to all this and it obviously didn't occur to him that there might have been previous discussion in the field...."
|