Quote:
Originally Posted by SleepyBob
But when a publisher sells a book, I can buy it. And then I can write and publish a "Cliff's Notes" version using the book that discusses important themes, characters, plot points and memorable quotes. And if I can do it as a person, there's a reasonable argument that a LLM should be allowed to do something similar. I don't see that as fundamentally different than what they already do. The publisher doesn't get to say "don't use this book to write a book about the book."
If I could get chatGPT to quote me a full chapter out of Harry Potter word for word, that would be one thing. But I'm pretty sure it can't.
|
You can do a review. You might need publisher permission for such extensive quotes, that's not fair use in many countries. Some don't even have a "fair use" law. Even in a review there may be a limit on what you can quote without written permission in many countries.
It's not the same thing, also the big corps didn't even buy a copy. They used pirate copies.
Totally false analogy that also reveals you don't understand how LLM work or copyright.