Quote:
Originally Posted by bertold
Of course. Everybody knew that they couldn't be the books. But that doesn't excuse the fact that they were bad.  |
I didn't think that any one of them were bad. there were at least two miserably done animated Hobbit films. THOSE were bad.
given the state of film making I think they did just about as well as could be expected. sure, in the LOTR the story was retold to some extent, but that did not detract from it being a visual feast to amaze, and the essence of the story was told.