Quote:
Originally Posted by salamanderjuice
Considering ripping a CD or recording TV with a VCR is also making copy without the permission of the rights holder yet are both considered fine today after court cases I don't think it's as clear cut as you make it out to be. Obviously IA lost this one but maybe with a more polished argument they could still win on appeal. Sometimes violation is necessary to prove its even acceptable. Otherwise we'd never know.
|
But IA were sharing the copy to the world.
I wrote:
Quote:
|
Was a copy made and distributed without the permission (needs to be in writing) of the copyright holder?
|
Highlight of original text.
Quote:
|
Considering ripping a CD or recording TV with a VCR is also making copy without the permission of the rights holder yet are both considered fine today after court cases
|
Not if you uploaded it or sold copies in the local market. Still not OK.