Quote:
Originally Posted by mezzanine
The example I used was the PW5 and the Oasis 3. You have one poster in this thread claiming there's a major difference between the two screens with the PW5 being inferior. Meanwhile, the general consensus among reviewers who have directly compared them head-to-head have concluded they're virtually indistinguishable.
Being skeptical when someone claims one Carta 1200 screen is clearly superior to another Carta 1200 screen seems reasonable.
|
Well, the poster claiming that doesn't own either device, so I don't take his opinion as a fact. I can well believe they're indistinguishable, but the thing is, the PW5 should be sharper/more contrasty, not the same, as it uses a newer screen. The Oasis 3 doesn't have a Carta 1200 screen. Why the PW5 isn't clearly better is anyone's guess.