View Single Post
Old 04-03-2009, 03:00 PM   #6
eljacob
Member
eljacob began at the beginning.
 
Posts: 10
Karma: 14
Join Date: Mar 2009
Device: PRS-700
Quote:
Originally Posted by Wetdogeared View Post
Is the resulting .lrf file still 18MB.?

Can anyone tell me if converting EBUP to LRF is always this much of a storage hog?

Was this a failure on Sony's part to not be able to properly display an EBUB book or a failure of the creator of the EPUB version for not using standards?

WDE.
Yes, the resulting LRF is still 18MB.

I really don't know why the file is so larger, if the "useful" content is still the same – same book, same text.

I don't believe the LRF file format is so inefficient as to waste so much more space in tags than with the actual book's content – we are talking of an increase of 640%, or almost 7 bytes in tags for each byte of useful information.

I am guessing it is probably something to do with calibre's conversion algorithm. As any generic algorithm, capable of converting whatever structure the authors create in a book, it cannot be as efficient as someone manually formating a book and placing only the right tags at the right places.

Again, I am only guessing, as I have never seen neither these file format documentations nor calibre's source code.

And, by the way, even if the increased size is due to calibre's algorithm I cannot complain about the application. I really prefer to waste this space if the alternative is not being able to read the book...

I was also curious about why the EPUB version didn't display properly. I sent a message to Pragmatic informing the problem, and I will post the reply here if I ever receive it.
eljacob is offline   Reply With Quote