Quote:
Originally Posted by Asiorent
I'm considering to order Nova and would like to ask you for a comparison with your Kindle. On another topic a member was complaining that his Mars has worse contrast for reading than his Kindle.
I'm planning to buy Onyx Boox Nova so how is your subjective feeling about the contrast and the reading on these three devices (Kindle, Nova, Mars)? If you compare only the reading experience how would you rate them?
It would be excellent if you could compare them with and without the light.
Thank you!
|
First of all, with the light off - contrast is practically identical between my Oasis 2 and my Nova. The Mars is very close.
With the light on? All I can offer you is a definite "it depends"! The Oasis 2 does not have a "comfort light" setting. So, all you get is the stark bluish-white "day" mode. Contrast is excellent.
The Mars and the Nova allow you to choose the "day" mode or a "night" or "comfort" mode - which has some orange tint blended in. You can adjust the degree of orange on either device. A free app you can download for the Nova on the Onyx app store allows for very precise blending of the two modes. The more orange you add, the less absolute contrast you will have. If you go fully in to "day" mode, contrast will be about the same for all three devices. But my eyes are happier with a little orange blended in, day and night. I never use the Oasis for reading now because i prefer less blue and a touch of orange tint. I may end up selling it.
(As an aside, be aware that some Mars users find that their devices have a heavier orange tint; others say theirs is more pale. I haven't heard the same from Nova users yet.)
As for the overall reading experience -
If you use mainly Kindle content, it's hard to argue against a Kindle device. The menus look nicer to the eyes, and you have more bells and whistles (like X-Ray) that the stock reader apps on the other devices would not have.
The Mars' stock reader app is fine, but with rough edges. For example, at the top left once you leave your book, you will see something like "3.4% readed". Page turning is as quick as the Kindle. Same is true for the Nova, but the Nova is a bit better on the English translations. All three allow you to change and add fonts. They all have the expected settings for margins and line spacing and so on. You may need to do a little fiddling to set up dictionaries with either the Mars or Nova, if you want one.
On the other hand, the stock reader apps on the Mars and the Nova will work with a wider variety of file formats than the Kindle. They handle pdfs quite well - limited only by the size of the display.
Of course, the main advantage of an Android-based E-Ink device is that you are not stuck with one ereader app. You can install any of a wide variety of reading apps, like Moon Reader, Librera or KOReader. Any one of these offers more options than either stock reader app. You can also install the Kindle Android app on either device. You can run the Nook app on the Nova, but not (yet) on the Mars, as far as I know. You could also install the Kobo app, Google Play Books, Pocket, Instapaper, or whatever. If you know about Calibre, you can take advantage of it more fully as well.
Battery life is mediocre with the Oasis 2. Other Kindles do better on that score. The Nova and the Mars have battery life similar to other Android tablets, and a bit better than the Oasis.
The Mars allows you to insert a microSD card and use it as adoptable storage - as though it were internal storage. You could slip a 128 gb card in there. The Nova has 32 gb of internal storage and no sd card slot. The Oasis comes in 8 gb and 32 gb flavors, with no sd card slot.
The Mars and the Nova each have a couple of minor but annoying idiosyncrasies. Not every owner has the same ones, though. For example, on my Nova, when I tap Google Play Store, every now and then it wants me to sign in again to my Google account. Future updates may fix these idiosyncrasies.
The bottom line? If you read only Kindle content, and don't care about the comfort light, go with the Oasis 2 or other Kindle. (The new Paperwhite may have a comfort light setting, or so I've heard.) If you want more reading options, a comfort light, and the maximum storage possible, go with the Mars. If you want the most reading options (including the Nook app), the comfort light, slightly better overall performance and good storage, go with the Nova.
None of these devices is without flaws. None will score 100% on anyone's wish list. But one will come closer to yours than the others. For me, the Nova and Mars are very close - with a slight edge to the Nova.
Not my "final answer", but it'll do!