Quote:
Originally Posted by DiapDealer
And you made up your mind by reading the opinions of people who agreed AND disagreed with Cotes' ruling (since you're not a lawyer and hence unqualified to interpret precedent)? Or did you merely focus on the opinions of other experts who shared your preconceived notion that she made incorrect rulings?
|
I read opinions on both sides. I read the original report that presented at the trial, as well as analysis on both sides of the questions of that report.
I've also read analysis of both sides on Cotes ruling, which is a very different issue. I've pointed to Jacobs' dissenting opinion of the appeal ruling a number of times here. Specifically, Jocobs said that "Apple took steps to compete with a monopolist and open the market to more entrants, generating only minor competitive restraints in the process". So it's not really the open and closed, Cote is the absolute authority situation that some want it to be.