How about a good discussion about a good book?!
Life is too short to read bad books. That being said, there's a big range between 'bad' and '5 stars'.

As long as we keep it 3 stars and above, I'm probably OK. S&B was only 2 stars because of the book club. Had I started it on my own? Would have been tossed in the first 20 pages and given a single star.