Maybe a good deal for some, but not for me. I don't listen to music all day every day now, nor did I do that when I was a teenager. I'm a casual, occasional listener. I find that I rarely get the message that a song is not available in my music library when listening to Prime Music. To be clear, my library has less than 100 songs in it. I'm just not a music nut like a lot of folks, and never have been. I prefer to tell Echo to play Classic Rock, or whatever genre floats my boat at the moment, and I get a decent selection of songs for FREE. Hardly worth another monthly fee just to get one or two extra songs a day. Perhaps this is because I was a child in the 1960s and a teenager in the 1970s and most of that music is so old that it is available in the Prime Music free catalog. Or maybe I'm just lucky to have most of what I want to hear available for free.