Yes, I can see that the book wouldn't have universal appeal - but then, does any book?! I loved all the weaving of stories - it was part of the magical feel of the book.
As for fulfilling the requirements, he did that. On page 56 of my paperback copy, the wording is
Quote:
|
The man who correctly named every eucalypt on the property would win the hand of his daughter, Ellen.
|
So technically, that is exactly what he did.
And that is quite in keeping with the fairytale element of the book. The hero often wins the hand (note the appropriate fairytale wording in the "decree") through a trick.
I love the book, but then I love fairy tales and enjoyed the way Bail used the style of the genre.
By the way, for people who find them interesting, I highly recommend Marina Warner, especially
From the Beast to the Blonde.