Quote:
Originally Posted by MikeB1972
I No Awarded both of them last year on the basis of not being sci-fi.
The fact that they were even nominated for a Hugo pretty much convinced me that the puppies had a point.
|
I thought there was a very slight argument that Wakulla Springs could be considered genre. At least, that's what I told myself when I voted for it.
Besides, neither of them won because the voters largely agreed with you. If the puppies point was that some works with dubious genre credentials can make the ballot occasionally, well they've definitely proven that.