Quote:
Originally Posted by DrNefario
"The Water that Falls on You from Nowhere"? Well, it's probably the water falling on you from nowhere part that makes it fantastical.
Wakulla Springs and "If You Were a Dinosaur, My Love" were the ones I had my doubts about, last year. I tell myself that the reason I voted against the latter was because it wasn't genre, but the truth is I just didn't like it as a story. I was happy enough to vote for Wakulla Springs because I did like it.
|
I No Awarded both of them last year on the basis of not being sci-fi.
The fact that they were even nominated for a Hugo pretty much convinced me that the puppies had a point.