I prefer Tom's list. This one has the two non-fiction categories grouped together rather than spreading them out and it tries to move the predefined categories around. Tom's is better distributed through the year.
Quote:
Originally Posted by JSWolf
Not good at all. Science Fiction NEEDS to be the category for September for any list to work.
|
Why?
July was set as Free-For-All prior to voting so that shouldn't be moved.
Quote:
|
However, I have one interesting idea that can work and is a bit different. If we take my list and swap December and January, we can have second chance be for January-November of 2016. That would work very well.
|
Non-starter, first because it was set as January prior to voting so shouldn't be moved. Second because having January as second chance makes the voting / nomination period for January (which happens in December) much easier during the holidays. Tom can just grab the
list and start a vote; he doesn't need to spend time with the nomination process which is the time consuming portion.