Quote:
Originally Posted by Blossom
I don't think Jamie is fully informed on the issue. She spoke out about the lawsuit before knowing everything which was not a smart thing to do. How she feels about DA though I think her feelings are justified. It was an ugly attack on her not a bad review. I am still scratching my head on why she was attacked and yet there are several books on DA that are much worse and they have a good review.  |
I didn't see any attack in that review at all. She is going through the characters and story. She gave it a C, which is still a pretty decent rating I think. I gave it a 1 star. Heck, she even calls the voice of the author compelling, so I am at a loss to see any attack here or why McGuire was flying off the handle.
I don't buy her being clueless about the lawsuit. This isn't the first time she stuck the foot in the mouth. There is a pattern.
I rarely agree with the reviews on Dear Author anyway, like I said, BD was a 1 star for me, I found it that bad, Jane gave it a C. Thats like a 3 star, which I give pretty decent books. Often their B's and A's are something I don't like and often their D's are stuff that I didn't find that bad. Still fun to check out the stuff. Once in a while I do find a gem this way.
