Quote:
Originally Posted by Sil_liS
The US courts have jurisdiction in the US, they don't have jurisdiction in Ireland. MS Has control of the information since they own the servers, but they also have legal responsibilities to the account owners.
Even if in the US the court can can dismiss people's rights and request the information, I don't see how you can possibly argue that their rights are extended to information that is stored on another country's territory.
|
Stop moving those goalposts. Previously, you claimed that Microsoft does not "own" the data, and thus cannot be forced to give it up. I argued that if so, then neither can they demand data that is stored in the US, since apparently only the owner has the right to relinquish the data.
Does what you say have anything to do with that back-and-forth?
If so, please elaborate.
If not, please do not quote me randomly, after you have moved on. It makes it very difficult to figure out what you are saying.