Quote:
Originally Posted by arspr
Well, with that interpretation, the long paragraph bug is not a bug also...
(Hey, you had room for the paragraph to start, but, what the hell, I prefer starting it in the next page!!! Widows & orphans are fully respected, so no bug at all).
|
That would violate the orphans setting, by not allowing the paragraph to start when at least two lines could be displayed at the end of a page and doing so would display at least two lines (with default settings) on the next page. GeoffR's example is a relatively rare instance where the paragraph is just the right size that there are two equally valid display solutions (3+2 and 2+3) and the engine must choose between them.
It is also possible to have a paragraph that is short enough and located such that there is no obvious way to simultaneously obey both the widows and orphans settings, therefore forcing one to take precedence...such as a three-line paragraph at the end of a page, W&O both set to 2, and room for two more lines on that page. Obeying W by displaying the first two lines violates O, so the only valid option is to
apparently violate W by skipping those two lines and showing all three on the next page. Yes, it's ugly, but it follows the rules.