Quote:
Originally Posted by faithbw
It would be nice if you could only rate a book after you marked the book status as read. Of course, people will mark the book as read to put in a rating. Honestly, I never understood why people who are really excited about a pre released book feel the need to rate it. Unless you have an ARC, it makes no sense and skews the ratings.
|
But, if the book in the shelf is either taken off or no longer marked as read, then the rating/review should be removed. That way, someone would have to clutter up his/her library with not read books just to leave bogus ratings/reviews. It would not be a case of mark the book read, rate it, write the review and delete the book from the shelf and have the rating/review remain.
But to be fair, I don't know what would happen to the rating if the book was removed from the shelf.