I actually follow a couple of review sites. But I've spent time sorting and finding ones I like. For urban fantasy and fantasy recommendations I use:
http://www.fantasyliterature.com/
For general--they cover urban fantasy and cozy mysteries as well as thrillers I like:
http://openbooksociety.com/
I also participate in a couple of goodreads forums and get some good recs from there.
The book I mentioned on my own blog today I found by reading this blog:
http://meanfatoldbat.blogspot.com/
Her husband has been very ill lately so she hasn't been reviewing/blogging much, but she reads some interesting stuff.
For indie books I often check:
http://papyrus.calebblake.net/
Our tastes don't align perfectly, but the reviews are good and I can get a pretty decent idea about whether I'd like the book or not.