I think part of the problem with these early reviews is that they are mostly done my electronics and/or high tech websites rather than hardcore eInk aficionados like us. That is, the reviewers are jacks of all trades but masters of none. In other words, they probably are not as well versed on eInk readers as we are, nor as interested in them. Also I noticed that some of the videos were shot at some sort of electronics show and thus more restricted in what they could do. But I agree, I wish someone would make a good video of the PW2 being used in a dark room.