Quote:
Originally Posted by Sil_liS
publishersweekly called it a "stellar debut", and while I'm sure that many are only seeing the word "stellar", it is the fact that it was viewed as a debut that makes me doubt her skill
|
You're entitled to your opinion obviously regarding the quality of writing, but it wasn't "viewed" as a debut, it WAS a debut. It was the first book published by Robert Galbraith. Publishers Weekly didn't know it was Rowling at the time. Them saying it is a debut is a simple statement of fact, not an assessment of writing skill.