Quote:
Originally Posted by Ak Mike
RickyMaveety - now you want me to do some real work! I think you probably agree with me that there is a strong individualist strain in American culture, and also that this country affords a much broader right of judicial remedy for individuals than other countries do (it's the source of many complaints about our lawyer-dominate culture - but lawyers can only do what the courts and legislatures let them do).
With respect, you are wrong in your suggestion in yesterday's post that where you can sue depends on where the injury occurred. You can sue anyone anywhere where you can get personal jurisdiction, at least in the U.S. I can sue you in California for an automobile accident that occurred in France. You can sue me in New York for breaking a contract with you in Turkey. I am confident that I could sue you in a Dutch court for slandering me in Illinois. What law applies may be an open question, but the courts in any jurisdiction are not limited to resolving disputes that arose in that jurisdiction.
|
I think that there is a very strong individualist strain in Alaska, but no .... I don't think all Americans are gung-ho members of the cult of individuality.
You are correct in that a court must have either subject matter or personal jurisdiction over the parties to a suit. I would be interested to hear how you would go about suing me in a Dutch court for slandering you in Illinois when you reside in Alaska and I reside in Texas. Please provide a citation ... I would be really interested in reading a case like that to see how they pulled personal jurisdiction out of a hat. I was in the Netherlands in 1969 ... are you saying that gives them personal jurisdiction over me for the remainder of my life??
No sarcasm here .... you are a litigator and I am emphatically not, so I'd really like to see where your information comes from.
And, yes .... of course I'm going to make you work. I expect everybody at this forum to work on making their posts understandable and either educational or unutterably silly.