xP Thanks a lot for trying you guys, lol. xD Duckie, it wasn't set to 'Invert', unfortunately, it was set to Comma.
And Dusky, that may be on the right track, but it wasn't quite it because it was a last name, first name after doing the Copy All Sort Values to Author"
Here's my current list of three books.
After Sundown - Amanda Ashley
American Gods - Neil Gaiman
According to Hoyle - Abigail Roux
They are listed in that order, but it should be
According to Hoyle - Abigail Roux
After Sundown - Amanda Ashley
American Gods - Neil Gaiman
because it would sort by Author's first name, not last name, lol.