Here's another alternative, if you want to roll your own aggregator:
Tiny Tiny RSS
I like the idea of not being beholding to another company that might any day close, so this project appeals to me.
However, I REALLY like Feedly on my phone (not so crazy about the website). It bookmarks to Instapaper, which I use for further reading for later or on my ereader. So I'll probably go with Feedly, for now. But, I'll be looking more into TTR again.
Who knows, maybe with Google closing down Reader (what's next Gmail?!) we might soon get even better alternatives, since, it seems, everyone who relied on RSS just used Reader.