View Single Post
Old 08-05-2008, 12:59 PM   #73
cstross
Cynic
cstross will become famous soon enoughcstross will become famous soon enoughcstross will become famous soon enoughcstross will become famous soon enoughcstross will become famous soon enoughcstross will become famous soon enough
 
Posts: 86
Karma: 514
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Edinburgh, Scotland
Device: Lots, started with a Psion 3 circa 1998
There's a fairly simple solution to the whole piracy problem, anyway -- not just books, but films and music and software too:

1. Legalize it,

2. Put a tax levy on all ISP mediated internet connections,

3. Organize a licensing agency to distribute the tax revenue to creators.

Part #3 is the hard bit, but if downloading of copyrighted media is legal, there's no reason for users to hide their activities, and so participating in a ratings scheme (to track popularity of downloads) shouldn't be problematic.

There are plenty of surveys out there that say most folks would be happy to pay on the order of $5-10 a month for legal, free, access to all the copyrighted media they can eat; pitch it at the public as "conscience money" and at the creative industries as their new, easy-to-administer revenue stream, and there you go: everybody wins, and we can forget all this nonsense about piracy and copyright infringement, and move on.

(Yes, there's a lot of detail work to sort out in order to make a system like this work, and the biggest issues are: disruptive new mesh networking technologies, and how to extend it internationally -- the internet takes little notice of borders. But I think it would certainly work better than the current mess ...)
cstross is offline   Reply With Quote