Quote:
Originally Posted by alansplace
|
This post (posted by me) was to show the participants in this thread that 'Cold Days' was the 4th most anticipated release in the genre for 2012 as the editors of Fantasy Faction interpreted it from the sources they listed.
Quote:
Originally Posted by JSWolf
I'm not so sure I can believe that list given the very large mistake they made. A Memory of Light is not the 3rd most anticipated Fantasy book in 2012. It is THE MOST ANTICIPATED fantasy book of 2012.
|
As I said above, "as the editors of Fantasy Faction interpreted it from the sources they listed". So where's the mistake? It was their interpretation of the sources they listed!?
Quote:
Originally Posted by alansplace
For crying out loud, what's there to believe!??! The site specifically states:
"top 10 releases of 2012 as chosen by our Readers, Twitter Fans, Forum Visitors and Goodreads Group Members"
So you'd vote/decide differently, SO WHAT!
|
Sorry, I got a little rude here, but I stand by that I said.
Quote:
Originally Posted by JSWolf
It's not about what I want to be #1. It's what really is #1. In order for me to read the Sanderson book, I'd have to start the series from the beginning. So for me, the only one that has any real meaning is the Dresden book because I am reading the series and eventually will get to it. The others are mostly book 2 of a series I have not read book one of.
|
Correct, it's not about what you want to be #1, agreed! But it's also not about what you claim "really is #1"! And it's also not about where someone is in their reading of any particular series. It's about the anticipation for the release of books that are scheduled to be released in 2012.
