View Single Post
Old 05-18-2008, 10:22 AM   #128
The Alternative
Techno-Junkie
The Alternative doesn't litterThe Alternative doesn't litter
 
The Alternative's Avatar
 
Posts: 74
Karma: 176
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Southeastern Wisconsin
Device: Sony Reader PRS-500 (x's 2), PRS-505, PRS-600, iPhone, iPad
Quote:
Originally Posted by HarryT View Post
Of course it's a derivative work! Copyright law allows limited quoting from a work for purposes of literary criticism, etc, but this hardly constitutes that.

Besides which, this is not a "fan guide", distributed free on the internet. It's a commercial publication. This is just a guy who's cynically trying to make money from Ms. Rowling's work.

Harry, if memory serves, this "Fan guide" was exactly that - a "lexicon" that was originally distributed freely on the internet. It wasn't until the content was gathered into a book form and scheduled for publication that Rowling objected and sued. Seems to me that Rowling's motive was clear - as long as no one was making money on it it was okay for everyone - the moment there was money to be made on it she "intejected."
The Alternative is offline   Reply With Quote