MobileRead Forums - View Single Post

AndyfromVA · 11-11-2011, 11:35 AM

I'm a longtime user of the Nook 1E. A few months ago I bought my tech-challenged wife a Kobo WiFi with 100 classics preloaded. Unsurprisingly she's never used it so I appropriated it. However recently she expressed a desire to access her email out of the house without having to use a cell phone so I bought her a Kindle Keyboard 3G. I have a feeling I'll probably appropriate this one as well.

So now I'm in a good position to evaluate these three models. Overall I like the Nook 1E the best, followed by the Kindle and then the Kobo, but each has pluses and minuses.

I love everything about the Nook 1E except for its thickness and weight. The touch screen works very well. I find swiping a very natural way to turn pages. The Nook is a quick machine in every respect and I find the e-ink screen to be perfectly adequate. But its thickness and weight are a definite negative, something which I didn't really appreciate until I started using the Kindle and Kobo.

The Kindle Keyboard 3G is a terrific machine, especially if you need the keyboard. It's at least as quick as the Nook and has a beautiful e-ink screen. It's thin and lightweight. But I find the tiny 4 way cursor to be really hard to use. Also while the page turning buttons work very well, they are not as natural a way to turn pages as the page swipe on the Nook

The Kobo WiFi is the thinnest and lightest of the three machines, which is a major plus. Its menu system is very user friendly and I like the large page turning/navigating 4 way cursor. Its e-ink screen is bright and easy to read. But it's a very slow machine, especially when you're used to the quicker Nook and Kindle.

11-11-2011, 11:35 AM	#1
AndyfromVA Zealot Posts: 127 Karma: 1002610 Join Date: Jun 2010 Device: Nook 1E, K3, K4, Paperwhite 2	Comparing Kindle, Kobo and Nook I'm a longtime user of the Nook 1E. A few months ago I bought my tech-challenged wife a Kobo WiFi with 100 classics preloaded. Unsurprisingly she's never used it so I appropriated it. However recently she expressed a desire to access her email out of the house without having to use a cell phone so I bought her a Kindle Keyboard 3G. I have a feeling I'll probably appropriate this one as well. So now I'm in a good position to evaluate these three models. Overall I like the Nook 1E the best, followed by the Kindle and then the Kobo, but each has pluses and minuses. I love everything about the Nook 1E except for its thickness and weight. The touch screen works very well. I find swiping a very natural way to turn pages. The Nook is a quick machine in every respect and I find the e-ink screen to be perfectly adequate. But its thickness and weight are a definite negative, something which I didn't really appreciate until I started using the Kindle and Kobo. The Kindle Keyboard 3G is a terrific machine, especially if you need the keyboard. It's at least as quick as the Nook and has a beautiful e-ink screen. It's thin and lightweight. But I find the tiny 4 way cursor to be really hard to use. Also while the page turning buttons work very well, they are not as natural a way to turn pages as the page swipe on the Nook The Kobo WiFi is the thinnest and lightest of the three machines, which is a major plus. Its menu system is very user friendly and I like the large page turning/navigating 4 way cursor. Its e-ink screen is bright and easy to read. But it's a very slow machine, especially when you're used to the quicker Nook and Kindle.