Quote:
Originally Posted by Rob Lister
P.S. This reminds me of my 9th(?) grade English class. Mrs. Munns assigned us The Red Pony by John Steinbeck. During the post-assignment class discussion, she commented that the book was really a series of short stories. She asked if everyone understood that. I disagreed, saying that since there was a clear underlying thread of plot through the book, which you really wouldn't get if you read just this chapter or that, it should be considered a novel. She asked the class if anyone disagreed with me. Everyone raised their hand. She looked at me as said, "Well, Mr. Lister. It seems everyone disagrees with you." I replied, "Since you and I are the only ones that actually read the book, and I have my doubts about you, I think I can ignore their opinion." She asked me to leave the class. I got detention.
P.P.S. On mature reflection, she was right, but at least I read the damn thing.
|
I'd say any teacher who doesn't try to refute an intelligent argument with an intelligent deserves no respect.
Instead of engaging with you, she shot you down by a vote. She deserved a whole lot less respect than you showed her.