Quote:
Originally Posted by tompe
What goal? If the goal is to experience the work in an optimal way they are not the same. For each text either reading or listening to it will be the optimal way to experience it. And I really think that for most texts reading is the optimal way because most text really demand that you can vary the speed you process the text.
|
This is *entirely* subjective. I hated "The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo" until I listened to it -- the narrator brought meaning and inflection to the text that I simply wasn't. Other people will feel differently than I in regard to that text, and their opinion is just as valid as mine because this is
subjective.
Tl;dr: This is a very silly argument.
