Quote:
Originally Posted by issybird
Does Jon ever participate? Or does he just like being a gadfly?
For me, personally, there's a lot of overlap in SF & F, and I don't especially like those genres. But I know others do, so I can try to broaden my horizons a bit or step back, in any given SF or F month. I think the list as it stands now does a good job of accomodating most tastes fairly.
This whole dustup smells a whole lot like one person trying to railroad through his own preference and in the process ignoring/misrepresenting any opposition.
|
Ok, except there are some of us who would like to see a change. So, we should automatically be ignored just because Jon made the suggestion?
This is not the first time
I have said that I would like to see another genre to replace the 2nd "classic" option and I am open to trying just about anything else.
Also, I have suggested a poll, so if the results come back that more people want to keep things the way they are then so be it.