Quote:
Originally Posted by JSWolf
Here's the summery as I've read it.
We have two classic categories. We've already used one. The next is coming up in December. Everyone so far who has chimed in has agreed to do away with the second classic. Nobody has spoken up saying to keep it.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by sun surfer
I like the categories the way they are now. 
I like two months of classics and don't see a need to define "classic"; we've done well enough without a definition already. |
Quote:
Originally Posted by issybird
Off the top of my head, what I'd like is to retain two classic months, but make one pre-20th century and one 20th-century only--if a change is felt necessary.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Hamlet53
On the subject of classics. Yes, the term does mean of a certain age and of a level of quality and importance that enough people still know the book and will nominate it and vote for it.
<snip>
Anyway looking at the list it does not look at all broken.
|
The kindest interpretation I can put on the assertion in the top post is that you couldn't be bothered to go back a page and check. Did you just assume that everyone must agree with you? Because surely you couldn't have deliberately tried to mislead everyone about the nature of the consensus?