I've been a competitive product analyst, product tester, and software product manager in the computer industry for decades, I have significant typographic and font-creation experience, and I'm very conscious of poor typography and lack of readability.
If a product in my hand has flaws, I'll find and document them. That's how products improve. Compliments may make a Product Manager feel good for a few hours, but do not serve any purpose in improving a product.
If you care to look, you will find that I've written comparable critiques on various Kindle forums and the Nook forum here. I'm an equal-opportunity griper, but I do give credit where credit is due, and not where it isn't.
The decision to ship half-baked software for an earlier ship date is always a difficult one, and in this case, I believe that it probably did not result in improving the long-run sales of the Kobo Touch, because the product was initially less-capable than the Nook II and got mediocre first reviews as a result = lost future sales.
If you disagree with my comments or can't stand the heat, stay out of the kitchen, but let's not be insulting to each other.
Last edited by EldRick; 06-29-2011 at 09:56 PM.
|