[jesscat]

Also, you can toggle this feature on an as-needed basis by clicking the little icon to the right of the search bar in the main window - it looks like three blue lines with a red diagonal line through it. You can click it and it will switch back and forth even on an active search - no need to go into preferences at all. (I switch between them all the time, so I'm really happy the toggle button is back - it was gone for a little while!)

EDIT: I just noticed that the red diagonal line on the icon toggles on and off; off for highlighted search, on for separate list of search results. So you might see only three blue horizontal lines. Anyway, it's to the right of the "reset search" button.