Reading the article it seems that most of the objection comes from the at odds actions of stating kids should be reading 50 books a year and then smacking down the funding of Public Libraries.
When my older kids were in Grade School I did a mini-parental revolt by refusing to fill out those "Free Reading Logs." Free reading shouldn't have to be logged, monitored, or approved by your Mommy. Nothing kills a bucket of fun quite like turning it into
homework.
I bought books and comics and Sports Illustrated magazines and I left them lying around the house and let nature take its course.